More biscuit, less bill…
In a cost-of-living crisis, every penny counts — and that includes the pennies we spend on our favourite snacks. But what if you didn’t have to sacrifice quality for savings? According to new data, supermarket own-brand treats are not just cheaper — they’re actually beating household-name brands on taste, value, and customer satisfaction.
In a study by product review site CritiqueJeu, researchers analysed more than a thousand snack-based shopping lists and online reviews to uncover the most popular — and best-rated — supermarket dupes for classic British treats. The results might surprise even the most loyal brand devotees.
Let’s start with a national treasure: the digestive biscuit. McVitie’s has long been the go-to name for tea dunkers across the country, but Sainsbury’s own-brand version is giving the original a run for its money. Scoring 4.4 stars (the same as McVitie’s), they’ll set you back just 2p per biscuit — less than half the price.
And it’s not just the digestives. McVitie’s Jaffa Cakes, a staple in many lunchboxes, are being outclassed by Morrisons’ version. At just 6p per cake and with a near-perfect 4.8 review score, they’re rated higher than the original — which costs more than twice as much.
Over in the crisp aisle, Walkers Quavers have met their match in Tesco’s Cheese Curls. The dupe costs just 14p per bag and comes in packs of 10 instead of six — plus, they’ve earned a stellar 4.8 out of 5 in customer reviews, comfortably ahead of Quavers’ 4.4.
Chocolate lovers aren’t left out either. Tesco has emerged as the unofficial king of snack dupes, dominating the top 10 with alternatives to KitKats (Snappy Fingers), Mars bars (Dreamy Caramel), and even Milky Way (Cosmic Whip). Many of these score higher than the originals and come with a much friendlier price tag — often 40–50% less per bar.
And for fans of frozen indulgence? Even Magnum ice creams have competition. Sainsbury’s Milk Chocolate Ice Cream Sticks, with an identical 4.7-star rating, cost half as much per serving. Same rich coating, same velvety centre — just more change left in your pocket.
The top supermarket swaps (that are actually better):
| Original | Best Dupe | Review Score | Cost/Serving |
|---|---|---|---|
| McVitie’s Digestives | Sainsbury’s Digestives | 4.4 | £0.02 |
| McVitie’s Jaffa Cakes | Morrisons Jaffa Cakes | 4.8 | £0.06 |
| Walkers Quavers | Tesco Cheese Curls | 4.8 | £0.14 |
| KitKat | Tesco Snappy Fingers | 4.7 | £0.17 |
| Twix | Tesco Crunchy Caramel Bars | 4.7 | £0.29 |
| Magnum Classic | Sainsbury’s Ice Creams | 4.7 | £0.50 |
In other words, brand loyalty might be costing you more than you realise. With dupes now matching — and often exceeding — the quality of big-name products, shoppers are redefining what counts as a “treat.”
So the next time you’re reaching for a Jaffa Cake or eyeing up a Magnum, it might be worth glancing at the shelf just below. Your wallet (and maybe your taste buds) will thank you.
