James Sutton to leave Hollyoaks again

James previously quit the show and had a spell in Emmerdale before returning, but now he’s off again…

James Sutton, one of Hollyoaks’ most recognisable faces, is set to depart the Channel 4 soap next year in a storyline described as “explosive”.

The actor first joined the show in 2006 as John Paul McQueen, quickly becoming central to some of its most memorable storylines. His character’s coming-out arc and later relationship with Craig Dean were hailed as groundbreaking at the time, winning praise from both fans and critics.

After two years, Sutton left the Channel 4 saga in 2008 to join Emmerdale, where he played mechanic Ryan Lamb until 2011. His tenure in the Yorkshire Dales saw his character embroiled in several dramatic plots, including a high-profile “who killed Mark Wylde?” storyline. Sutton later returned to Hollyoaks in 2012, with John Paul once again becoming central to the McQueen family’s fortunes. He left briefly again in 2017 before reprising the role once more from 2019 onwards.

John Paul and Craig the first ‘happy ever after’ exit that wasn’t to be happy ever after / Lime Pictures
“I Don’t” Jes and John Paul in Hollyoaks / Lime Pictures

Confirming his exit, a source close to the production said Sutton had “loved his time” on the show but was looking to explore new opportunities. “It’s not a goodbye to acting,” they added, “but it’s not going to be the only thing he does now.” Sutton has reportedly been developing projects linked to fitness and men’s mental health, areas in which he has spoken openly about his own personal journey.

The departure comes as Hollyoaks gears up to mark its 30th anniversary next month, with showrunner Hannah Cheers promising “a huge month of celebrations” alongside the soap’s trademark high-stakes stunt episodes. “You can’t do a Hollyoaks commemoration without some kind of spectacle,” she said.

There is also to be a tribute to former Channel 4 drama serial Brookside within the Hollyoaks anniversary week of episodes.

John Paul McQueen: Timeline

1989 – Early Life

  • Born to Myra McQueen.

  • Raised by his mother and sisters; unaware of his father’s identity until later, when he learned his parent transitioned and became Sally St. Claire.


2006–2008: Arrival in Hollyoaks & Craig Affair

  • Arrives with the McQueen family.

  • Comes out as gay after kissing best friend Craig Dean.

  • Dates DJ Spike, but begins an affair with Craig.

  • Craig struggles with his sexuality; John Paul leaves for Dublin with him in 2008.


2008: Relationship with Kieron Hobbs

  • Engages in a secret relationship with Catholic priest Kieron Hobbs.

  • Engagement ends when Craig returns.

  • John Paul and Craig reconcile and leave for Dublin together.

2012–2013: Return with Baby Matthew

  • Matthew-Jesus McQueen was born on Christmas Day 2012 and is the son of John Paul McQueen and Craig Dean, and the surrogate son of Chloe Chance.
  • Returns to Hollyoaks with son Matthew after splitting from Craig.

  • Begins work as a teacher at Hollyoaks High.

  • Short relationships with Doug Carter and Danny Lomax, both turbulent.


2014–2015: Rape Storyline & Ste Hay Marriage

  • Suffers sexual assault by student Finn O’Connor.

  • Struggles with trauma but eventually testifies, leading to Finn’s conviction.

  • Begins a relationship with Ste Hay; they marry, but it collapses after Ste’s HIV diagnosis and drug problems.


2015–2017: Affairs & Departure

  • Affair with Porsche’s husband Lockie Campbell.

  • Short-lived relationship with Scott Drinkwell, then James Nightingale.

  • Cheats on James with Ste.

  • Leaves Hollyoaks for a teaching job in Singapore with Matthew, later reuniting with Craig.

2019–2020: Returns to Hollyoaks

  • Cameo video call in 2019 for Myra’s wedding.

  • Full return in December 2019.

  • Discovers Finn has been released from prison, confronts him.

  • Becomes embroiled in Breda McQueen’s serial killer storyline.


2020–2021: Relationship with George Kiss

  • Starts relationship with police officer George Kiss.

  • Relationship turns abusive; John Paul is manipulated, gaslit, and assaulted.

  • George is murdered; John Paul is wrongfully imprisoned before Sally clears his name.


2022–Present: Alcoholism and Recovery

  • Struggles with alcoholism following Sylver’s death.

  • Neglects responsibilities while drinking in secret.

  • Confronted by family, including his son Matthew, about his drinking.

  • Begins a journey of recovery, showing his long-term resilience despite trauma.