“Bigger, bolder and better than ever”
It is not often that a theology dissertation makes for riotous theatre. But Mimi Nation-Dixon, a Durham graduate with a First in Theology, has managed to do just that. Her debut play, Sit or Kneel, which opens at The Other Palace Studio in Victoria later this month, transforms her academic interest in the way Richard Curtis presented women clergy on screen into a sharply observed, darkly funny exploration of what it means to be young, female and ordained in modern Britain.
Margot, the play’s protagonist, is hardly the picture of saintly certainty. Accidentally ordained in her twenties, she finds herself leading a parish she neither understands nor entirely respects, while privately struggling with grief, ambition and the relentless pressure to be fine at all times. As casserole dishes arrive unbidden at her door, so too does the creeping realisation that she might be unravelling.
Nation-Dixon describes the play as “somewhere between Fleabag and The Vicar of Dibley” — the wit of the former meeting the village eccentricities of the latter. Yet there is an edge here that neither of those touch: a critique of expectation, gender and the strangeness of church life in a country where, even thirty-three years after the Church of England voted to allow women priests, fewer than a quarter of paid clergy posts are filled by women.
The playwright herself grew up in rural England, in a community where the rituals of small-town life — gossip, casserole diplomacy, the theatre of Sunday services — shaped her sense of comedy. That intimacy gives the show its authenticity: the quirky villagers feel lived-in rather than caricatured, their advice both meddlesome and strangely moving.
Following a sold-out run at the Edinburgh Fringe, Sit or Kneel now returns “bigger, bolder and better than ever”. It has already drawn comparisons to the work of Phoebe Waller-Bridge for its mix of acerbic humour and vulnerability. Critics have been quick to spot Nation-Dixon’s promise: The Scotsman called her “witty, cerebral and smart”, while First Night declared, “this is the start of something quite big”.
Indeed, the play has already spawned a television pilot. Nation-Dixon hopes to expand the story into a series that captures not just the singular Margot, but the ensemble of characters that make up her parish — an affectionate nod to the oddities of British village life.
In a cultural moment where comedy is increasingly a vehicle for questions of identity, faith and belonging, Sit or Kneel feels timely. It balances irreverence with empathy, offering audiences laughter that lingers long after curtain call.
Perhaps, in Margot’s messy attempts to lead a congregation while finding herself, we glimpse something larger: the universal difficulty of carrying other people’s expectations while trying to remain true to one’s own.
Sit or Kneel runs 21–26 October at The Other Palace Studio
