Podcast reveals shocking story of parents jailed for a crime that never happened

RTÉ Doc on One and RTÉ Investigates join forces for the first time in First Conviction, a new six-part podcast and television documentary series…

A new RTÉ podcast and documentary series tells the extraordinary story of a couple who were jailed for a crime that, it later emerged, never took place.

First Conviction, from the award-winning RTÉ Documentary On One team and RTÉ Investigates, charts the near decade-long fight to clear their names after being accused in 2016 of harming their young daughter. Both were convicted and imprisoned in 2019 before their convictions were overturned – a case that has raised troubling questions about how Ireland’s justice and child protection systems operate.

The series, narrated by Oscar-nominated actor Ruth Negga, follows the accused from the day their daughter was taken to hospital with an injury, through years of investigation, prosecution and imprisonment, to their ongoing legal battle to be formally exonerated.

According to RTÉ, the parents always maintained their innocence, offering an explanation for their daughter’s injury that was rejected by medical staff and later by state agencies. Charged by Gardaí in 2017, they spent more than three years awaiting trial and say they felt abandoned by their community.

When the trial finally took place in 2019, both were convicted and sentenced to prison. Their children were placed in the care of relatives under state supervision. After more than two years behind bars, an appeal court ruled their convictions were unsound, releasing them on bail and ordering a retrial.

A second, inconclusive trial followed, before fresh expert medical evidence supported the couple’s account of what had happened. The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) eventually withdrew all charges, entering a nolle prosequi – ending the prosecution but leaving the family in a state of legal uncertainty.

Now, almost ten years after their ordeal began, the couple remain before the courts seeking certificates of miscarriage of justice to officially clear their names. Only then, they say, will they be able to explain the full story to their children – and prove that they were innocent all along.

The RTÉ team spent more than a year interviewing the couple, as well as lawyers, medical experts and those involved in the case, to piece together a detailed picture of how the system failed.

The first two episodes of First Conviction are available now on all major podcast platforms, with new episodes released weekly. The series will also air on RTÉ Radio 1 and will conclude with a television documentary from the RTÉ Investigates team on 12 November on RTÉ One and RTÉ Player.