Sabrina Carpenter: Streaming darling, annoyance queen…
As the annual Spotify Wrapped leaves its mark for another year, global searches for “When does Spotify Wrapped come out?” have surged by an extraordinary 5,000% in the past month, as listeners braced themselves for the data-driven judgment day that will reveal, embarrass, or vindicate their 2025 listening habits.
But if Wrapped is a celebration of fandom, this year it’s arriving with a countermelody: a quiet, persistent debate about the tracks that defined the year for all the wrong reasons.
According to a new analysis by ticketing platform SeatPick, some of 2025’s biggest chart successes also rank among its most irritating songs that have racked up streams while simultaneously fraying public patience.
SeatPick examined the year’s major releases—drawing from Apple Music charts and official rankings—and measured four markers of “annoyance”: repetition, shrillness, harmonic dullness and filler lyrics. The result is a data-fuelled league table of the songs most likely to drive listeners round the bend.
At the top—twice—is Sabrina Carpenter, whose stratospheric year has included a Grammy, an iHeartRadio win, and Billboard domination. But SeatPick’s data paints a more conflicted picture of her 2025 output.
Both “Sugar Talking” and “Tears”, from the hit album Man’s Best Friend, score a striking 46% likelihood that listeners will find them annoying. The culprit? According to the analysis, a mix of melodic repetition and harmonic flatness.
Yet the controversy hasn’t dented Carpenter’s momentum: both tracks remain among the year’s most-streamed, their so-called irritating qualities apparently doubling as addictive hooks.
In third place is Lady Gaga’s theatrical 2025 single “The Dead Dance”, with a 45.8% irritation score. The track—bright, baroque, and lyrically maximalist—has been praised by fans for its operatic ambition but critiqued by others for excess. SeatPick highlights filler lyrics and sharp tonal spikes as drivers of annoyance.
Still, it’s been another decorated year for Gaga, who picked up a Grammy for “Die With a Smile”. That track also makes the annoyance dataset—with a 39.4% rating—but still comfortably sits in Wrapped playlists globally.
The top five rounds off with Jimin’s “Who”—45.5% annoying, per SeatPick—and David Guetta & Sia’s “Beautiful People” at 45.2%. Both tracks lean into high-octane production and relentless repetition, two of the analysis’ key irritants.
Jimin’s ranking comes as BTS prepare for their long-anticipated 2026 reunion, making any controversy around solo material unlikely to disrupt fan optimism.
SeatPick also analysed 2025’s most pervasive TikTok tracks, a category increasingly distinct from traditional charts.
The most irritating TikTok hit, topping the list at 45.7%, is “Dame Un Grrr” by Fantomel and Kate Linn—an explosive, looping earworm that has powered more than 1.2 million videos. Its “catchy-to-a-fault” structure is precisely what fuels both virality and fatigue.
Other viral offenders include Ca$h Out’s “She Twerkin” (44.1%), BubaJuice’s meme-driven “ACE UP” (44%), and PinkPantheress’s glitchy “Illegal” (44%), all of which embody TikTok’s bias toward short, repeatable sonic moments.
And in a slightly ironic twist, Jess Glynne’s “Hold My Hand”—a song already licensed to saturation for Jet2Holidays—lands joint seventh, with a 42.1% annoyance score after being used in more than 3.4 million TikTok posts. What began as an uplifting dance-pop track has, for many, become shorthand for algorithmic overexposure.
The SeatPick data arrives at a moment when Spotify Wrapped has become less a recap of the year than a ritual of self-branding. The tension between enjoyment and irritation—between the songs listeners love and the ones they can’t escape—is increasingly part of the conversation.
2025’s charts have been full of tracks engineered for maximum replayability, whether for TikTok loops, streaming optimisation or global pop crossovers. The industry knows repetition works. The annoyance index simply confirms the shadow side of that success.
Carpenter, Gaga, Jimin and others may dominate the year’s most irritating list, but they also dominate the year’s metrics: viral traction, sales, awards and streaming milestones. Annoyance, in the algorithmic era, might just be another word for impact.
