For years, Christmas advertising has been an arms race of sentiment, spectacle and softly deployed emotion.
But new research suggests that, in 2025, the British public may finally have drawn a line under too much festive wizardry – particularly when it comes courtesy of AI.
Analysis from William Hill Vegas, using social media monitoring tool Brandwatch, indicates that the most digitally driven Christmas adverts of the season have landed with a thud, while more traditional, human-centred storytelling has quietly reasserted its dominance.
Tracking positive sentiment on X between 17 November and 16 December, the research paints a clear picture: audiences want warmth, not whizz-bang effects.

At the bottom of the festive table sits Coca-Cola, whose fully AI-generated Christmas campaign recorded just 26% positive sentiment, making it the least popular advert of the year. That’s a notable fall for a brand once synonymous with Christmas advertising itself – and perhaps a sign that viewers are growing weary of high-gloss, computer-led magic in a season defined by nostalgia.
Just above it was Sainsbury’s, whose effects-heavy The Unexpected Guest – featuring the BFG – managed 33%, struggling to persuade audiences that spectacle alone can substitute for emotional connection.
In contrast, adverts that leaned into recognisable faces, gentle humour and grounded narratives performed far more strongly. Waitrose topped the table on 66% positive sentiment, narrowly beating John Lewis on 62% and Lidl on 61%. All three favoured character-led storytelling with minimal reliance on digital effects, echoing a style that feels almost countercultural in an era of AI-generated everything.
Marks & Spencer landed comfortably mid-table on 56%, while Boots narrowly missed out on a top-half finish with 49%. Further down, supermarket heavyweights Tesco and Aldi were level on 43%, ahead of Asda on 39%, whose Grinch-themed campaign failed to recapture the affection it enjoyed last year.

Lee Phelps, spokesperson for William Hill Vegas:
“Christmas advertising has always been about emotion, nostalgia and shared experiences, and this year the UK public seem to have made it clear that too much digital interference can get in the way of that.
“The two lowest-rated campaigns, according to our research, both relied heavily on computer-generated imagery. That contrast is striking when you look at the top of the table, where brands like Waitrose, John Lewis and Lidl focused on simple, human storytelling.”
None of this suggests AI is heading for the advertising scrapheap. But Christmas, it seems, remains stubbornly analogue in spirit.
In a season built on ritual and repetition, viewers still want adverts that feel made by – and for – people, rather than something conjured entirely by a machine.
As Phelps puts it: “AI will no doubt continue to play a role in advertising, but at Christmas in particular, viewers still want something that feels real. The message from the public this year is that festive magic can’t be manufactured entirely by a computer.”
