Same old telly offerings saw viewers turn to alternative entertainment…
Christmas Day television is still sold as a moment of national communion – a time when millions supposedly gather around the same programmes, at the same time, as they always have.
This year’s overnight ratings suggest that while the habit hasn’t vanished, it may be quietly thinning out.
At the top of the Christmas Day chart sat The King’s Speech with 4.6 million, followed closely by Julia Donaldson adaptation The Scarecrows’ Wedding on 4.3 million, and the Strictly Come Dancing Christmas Special on 4.2 million.
It’s a perfectly respectable line-up, but one that also underlines how modest the bar has become for festive “hits”.

Elsewhere in the top ten, the pattern was strikingly familiar: Michael McIntyre’s The Wheel (3.7m), Call the Midwife (3.4m), a Gladiators Christmas Special (3.2m), Amandaland (3.1m), and a clutch of long-running quiz formats.
Comfort viewing, certainly – but also a reminder that Christmas schedules across both BBC and ITV are leaning harder than ever on the known quantities.
The Beeb, understandably, is keen to stress the positives. Chief Content Officer Kate Phillips pointed out that the corporation occupied nine of the top ten slots, calling it “a timely reminder that shared moments really do still matter even in a world of so much choice”.
She also noted that BBC One was the biggest channel of the day and that the corporation’s total share exceeded the entire SVOD market combined on Christmas Day.

All of which is true – and yet slightly beside the point. Dominating a quieter landscape doesn’t automatically signal creative health. Being the biggest fish matters less if the pond itself is shrinking.
That sense of unease was most obvious in the performance of EastEnders, which endured a bruising Christmas despite heavy promotion and big storyline promises.
The soap’s first Christmas Day episode drew 2.8 million, with the second slipping further to 2.2 million, leaving it outside the day’s top ten altogether. That represents a drop of around two million viewers compared with last year – a significant fall for what has historically been one of the BBC’s festive cornerstones.
This was meant to be a big one. The Christmas Eve episode had ramped up multiple plots – Zoe’s stalker, Max discovering Jack’s betrayal, and the return of Chrissie Watts – and the Christmas Day climax delivered arrests, confrontations and melodrama in abundance. But for many viewers, it simply didn’t land.

Reaction on social media was unforgiving. One long-term fan wrote that the show had “lost its way”, calling it “the worst EastEnders since I started watching it in the late 80s”.
ATV Today editor Shaun Linden was blunter still, describing it as “the worst Xmas ep I’ve ever seen”. Behind the scenes, the soap’s recent change of producer has already attracted criticism, with some viewers feeling that recent progress has been undone – a familiar cycle at BBC Elstree.
ITV’s soaps fared little better. Neither Emmerdale nor Coronation Street made the top ten, pulling in 1.82 million and 1.91 million respectively for their hour-long episodes. The decision to serve up extended helpings of bleak storylines on Christmas Day appeared to test audience patience, with viewers seemingly less inclined than ever to sit through prolonged misery during what is supposed to be a festive pause.

Taken together, the figures paint a picture of a Christmas schedule that feels increasingly risk-averse.
The big broadcasters still win by default, but largely by recycling the same brands, formats and tones year after year. The audience turns up – just not in the numbers it once did, and perhaps not with the same enthusiasm.
Christmas Day television isn’t broken. But these ratings suggest it may be running on muscle memory rather than momentum. Shared moments still matter, as the BBC rightly says – but shared habits only endure if they continue to feel worth sharing.

