“A System That Isn’t Fair”: Retailers Demand VAT Reform on Online Marketplaces

Business groups warn loopholes are costing the Treasury millions — and putting UK shops at risk

Britain’s independent retailers are calling for urgent action over what they describe as a deeply unfair tax system that allows some overseas sellers to undercut honest UK businesses online.

The British Independent Retailers Association (Bira), alongside a coalition of 18 business organisations and tax experts, has written to the Exchequer Secretary to the Treasury demanding a formal consultation on reforming VAT rules for online marketplaces.

At the heart of their concern is a loophole that allows some foreign sellers to avoid paying VAT by misrepresenting themselves as UK-based. Independent analysis suggests this could be costing the Exchequer around £700 million a year — money that could otherwise support public services and domestic businesses.

“An Uneven Playing Field”

Online marketplaces have become essential for modern retail. They offer small businesses access to national and global audiences with relatively low risk. But retailers argue that the current VAT system is undermining those benefits.

Under existing rules, marketplaces are only required to collect and remit VAT on certain transactions involving non-UK sellers. Some dishonest traders exploit this by falsely claiming UK status, allowing them to sell goods without VAT and at lower prices.

The result, says Bira, is an uneven playing field.

Honest businesses — many already struggling with rising energy bills, rent, and staffing costs — are forced to compete with sellers enjoying a built-in tax advantage. For smaller firms, that margin can mean the difference between survival and closure.

A Call for Marketplaces to Take Responsibility

The coalition is urging the Government to extend VAT liability rules so that online platforms themselves become responsible for ensuring VAT compliance.

Supporters of reform argue this would:

  • Reduce fraud
  • Protect tax revenues
  • Level competition between UK and overseas sellers
  • Increase trust in online shopping

Jeff Moody, Chief Operating Officer at Bira, says the issue goes beyond tax policy. It’s about fairness.

Retailers are not asking for special treatment, he stresses — only for consistent rules that apply to everyone selling into the UK market.

Protecting Small Sellers

One of the key concerns surrounding reform is its potential impact on microbusinesses and sole traders, particularly those below the VAT registration threshold.

The coalition says these fears are legitimate — but manageable. Any new system, they argue, should be designed to exclude unregistered businesses and avoid creating extra administrative burdens for the smallest sellers.

“Our aim isn’t to penalise legitimate entrepreneurs,” the letter states. “It’s to stop fraud.”

Warnings from Parliament

Concerns about online VAT fraud are not new.

The Public Accounts Committee has repeatedly warned that abuse through digital marketplaces is increasing. Meanwhile, the National Audit Office has highlighted weaknesses in enforcement and oversight.

Both bodies have argued that existing systems have failed to keep pace with increasingly sophisticated methods used by fraudulent sellers.

For retailers, this strengthens the case for reform. Parliament, they say, has already recognised the problem. Now it needs to act.

Why This Matters Now

Retail is more competitive than ever. High streets are under pressure. Online margins are tight. Consumer confidence remains fragile.

In this environment, even small pricing advantages can reshape markets. When VAT isn’t applied consistently, compliant businesses lose customers — not because their products are worse, but because they’re playing by the rules.

Extending marketplace liability, campaigners argue, would restore confidence that competition is fair and transparent. It could also provide a major boost to public finances at a time when every pound counts.

“Time for Action”

In their closing message to Government, the coalition makes its position clear: delay is no longer an option.

They are urging ministers to launch a consultation as soon as possible, signalling a commitment to tackling fraud, supporting legitimate businesses, and protecting tax revenues.

“We stand ready to engage constructively,” the letter concludes.

For thousands of independent retailers watching overseas competitors undercut them online, that consultation cannot come soon enough.