As BrewDog shareholders face losing their stakes following the £33m sale of its UK brewing arm to Tilray, experts say government-backed venture schemes offer far stronger protection for investors
The collapse of the crowd-funded dream behind craft brewer BrewDog has become a cautionary tale for small investors, highlighting the stark difference between buying into a flashy start-up and investing through government-backed venture schemes that offer meaningful tax protection.
Thousands of retail shareholders who bought into BrewDog’s much-publicised Equity for Punks crowdfunding campaign now face the prospect of seeing their stakes wiped out after the company agreed to sell its UK brewing operations to US beverage and medical cannabis group Tilray for £33m — a fraction of BrewDog’s once-lofty valuation.
While the Equity for Punks scheme helped fuel BrewDog’s rapid expansion and brand mythology, it offered none of the tax advantages available to investors in government-supported venture capital programmes.
Susannah Streeter, chief investment strategist at Wealth Club, says the episode underlines the importance of understanding how — and where — you invest in early-stage companies.
“The sad saga of BrewDog highlights how investors in start-ups and scale-ups need to do their homework and opt for schemes offering them protection if the investment turns sour,” she says. “Many Equity Punks were attracted by flashy marketing, but the prospectus did make clear they risked losing their money.”
By contrast, investors in formal venture schemes receive tax incentives designed to offset the high risks involved in backing young businesses.
Under the government-backed Venture Capital Trusts (VCTs), investors currently receive 30% upfront income tax relief, though this is scheduled to fall to 20% from April. Returns from VCT investments are also tax-free.
Meanwhile the Enterprise Investment Scheme (EIS) offers 30% income tax relief, alongside the ability to defer capital gains from other investments while the money remains invested.
The more early-stage focused Seed Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS) provides even more generous incentives, including up to 50% income tax relief and the ability to offset half of certain capital gains tax liabilities.
These schemes also provide some protection if investments fail. When losses are combined with tax reliefs, the effective risk can be significantly reduced. A £10,000 EIS investment that fails entirely, for example, could leave a higher-rate taxpayer losing as little as £3,850. Under SEIS, the loss could be reduced to around £1,550.
There are conditions: investors must hold EIS and SEIS investments for at least three years, and VCT holdings for five.
For seasoned investors, these incentives recognise a simple reality: many young companies will fail. But by investing through structured schemes or diversified funds, the risk can be spread across multiple ventures — increasing the chances that a few successes will outweigh the inevitable losses.
For those tempted by the next start-up success story, Streeter says the lesson from BrewDog’s fall is straightforward: read the prospectus carefully and understand exactly what protections, if any, come with the investment.
