Pick of the Plots: Weekly Awards

The weekly gong event that doesn’t give out any trophies, just opinions…

Ah, the moment we’ve all been waiting for—time to hand out some highly dramatic (and occasionally deeply unserious) ATV Today Soap Awards. No red carpet, just vibes and strong opinions.


Best Soap (The “Just Tell the Story” Award)

EastEnders
No contest this week.

From Nigel’s final scenes to Phil’s chaotic-but-beautiful grieving process, this was stripped-back storytelling done perfectly.

No gimmicks, no distractions—just writing, acting, and emotional punches landing exactly where they should. That chair scene alone? Straight into the soap hall of fame.

The last goodbye this week in EastEnders / BBC

Most Devastating Moment (The “I Wasn’t Ready” Award)

Hollyoaks – Diane in the bath
Absolutely harrowing. No explosions, no villains—just the quiet, terrifying reality of Diane’s body failing her. Tony’s reaction, the kids helping… it was painfully grounded and all the more upsetting for it.


Biggest Punch (Literal & Metaphorical)

Home and Away – Cash decking Tane
Nothing says “friendly reunion” like immediate violence. Bonus points for turning a dusty driveway into a full-on Western showdown. Emotional punches also awarded to Jo realising she may have just ruined everything. Tough day all round.


Smartest Move (The “Finally, Someone With Sense” Award)

Home and Away – David strong-arming the DPP
A rare soap moment where someone uses their power effectively. Threaten to resign, call out the system, get results. Lacey walking free? We love to see it.


Worst Decision (The “What Did You Think Would Happen?” Award)

Home and Away – Abigail going to the press
We’ve watched this unfold in slow motion all week. Ignored advice, didn’t tell Lacey, triggered a legal nightmare. Even she knows she messed up now. Painful, avoidable, textbook soap error.


Most Likely Suspect (The “Honestly, Could Be Anyone” Award)

Coronation Street – Everyone
Theo’s dead and the suspect list is basically the cast sheet. Todd? Motive. George? Motive. Gary? Definitely motive. Carl? Always suspicious. At this point, the scaffolding might’ve done it.

Best Performance (The “Give Them All the Awards” Award)

EastEnders ensemble (Phil, Nigel, Grant, Julie)
This was a team effort. Quiet, layered, completely believable. The kind of acting that makes you forget you’re watching a soap and not just… life unfolding.


Most Unhinged Moment (The “What Am I Watching?” Award)

EastEnders – Phil burning his armchair
Arson? As grief therapy? Followed by a wholesome community wake? It should not work—and yet somehow, it really, really did.


Best Slow-Burn Villainy (The “Smiling Assassin” Award)

Emmerdale – Dr Todd
No shouting, no scheming monologues—just quietly ruining Jacob’s life one conversation at a time. Iconic in a low-key, deeply irritating way.


The Wonky Angle Award (Presented by ITV’s Missing Tripod Fund)

Coronation Street
Congratulations to Corrie for committing—fully—to the bit. This week the camera work has been… interpretive. Bold. Occasionally nausea-inducing. Please locate a spirit level before next week. Our eyes can’t take much more.


Quietest Heartbreak (The “Staring Into the Distance” Award)

Emmerdale – Paddy at the pub doorway
No dialogue needed. Just a man, his village, and the crushing fear that everything’s about to change. Simple, effective, ouch.

Most Explosive Week Overall (The “No One Had a Calm Day” Award)

Coronation Street
Attempted murder, actual murder, assault, sabotage, emotional breakdowns—honestly, it’s easier to list what didn’t happen.


Unexpected Win (The “Wait… That Ended Well?” Award)

Home and Away – Lacey’s charges dropped
In a week full of chaos, one storyline actually gave us resolution and justice. A rare, beautiful unicorn in Soapland.


Same time next week? Because at this rate, we may need to introduce a “Most Traumatic Cliffhanger” category…