Soap Round-up: Tuesday 19 May

Pick of the Plots review with Craig T. Cameron

Tuesday’s soaps were powered almost entirely by people making terrible emotional decisions under immense pressure — which, to be fair, is exactly what soaps do best.

Across every square, village and bay, relationships were tested, secrets edged closer to exposure and several characters found themselves trapped by problems of their own making.

5 Star at 6.30pm, stream on 5

Home and Away continues to juggle emotional intimacy with simmering conflict remarkably well. Mali and Abigail’s post-breakup awkwardness feels painfully authentic — all forced politeness, miscommunication and mutual frustration.

Poor Lacey getting dragged into the middle of it all gives the storyline some much-needed humour too. Mali sending her to collect the board was obviously doomed from the start, and Abigail instantly clocking that he was avoiding her felt entirely believable. Lacey eventually snapping and refusing to be the emotional courier for two stubborn exes was honestly deserved.

The strongest material, though, belongs to Dana and Sonny. The show has smartly avoided turning Dana into a villain; instead, her overprotectiveness comes from genuine fear and love. That’s what makes Eden’s intervention so effective.

Her point — that Dana needs to stop acting like Sonny’s full-time carer and start acting like his partner again — lands because everyone can see the imbalance except Dana herself. Sonny reclaiming a bit of independence by involving Remi is quietly empowering too. Their final scene together is genuinely lovely, built on reassurance rather than melodrama.

Remi’s storyline, meanwhile, takes a heartbreaking turn. His frustration over aphasia is written with uncomfortable realism, especially the exhaustion that comes from constantly fighting your own brain. The journal scenes are particularly strong because both characters are understandable:

Eden’s concern comes from love, but reading his private thoughts is still a betrayal. Remi catching her in the act has the sting of something deeply personal being exposed without consent, and the self-loathing revealed in the journal paints a bleak picture of where his mental state is heading.

Then there’s Brax. Ricky’s horror after seeing him fight taps into a long-running truth about the character: no matter how much he changes, violence always sits just beneath the surface. Casey questioning whether his father is actually a good man adds emotional weight to the storyline, because suddenly this isn’t just about River Boys anymore — it’s about legacy, fear and what kind of example Brax is setting for his son.

E4 at 7pm, stream on Channel 4

Hollyoaks is in full pressure-cooker mode right now, with nearly every storyline orbiting guilt, grief or manipulation. Charlie’s interrogation scenes are particularly tense because you can feel the walls closing in around him.

The show has done a solid job portraying how panic leads people into increasingly disastrous choices, and Frankie changing her statement only deepens the sense that this situation is spiralling beyond control.

The contrast between the grieving Hutchinson family and the almost celebratory atmosphere surrounding Charlie being charged is deeply uncomfortable — intentionally so. Jonah, Beth and Caleb treating the news like a victory creates a morally murky atmosphere that Hollyoaks thrives in. Nobody really comes out clean.

Ant snapping at Mercedes outside The Dog is another small but effective grief moment. Emotions are raw, irrational and unpredictable, while Jenson stepping in for Mercedes further cements his growing role as an unexpected emotional anchor.

Ironically, Warren’s attempt to get rid of him completely backfires. Jenson using the money to help Prince instead is one of the episode’s strongest turns — generous, impulsive and immediately dangerous once Warren decides that debt now belongs to him instead.

And Warren secretly installing cameras in the McQueens’ house? Pure soap villain behaviour. It’s creepy, invasive and exactly the kind of controlling move that shifts him from morally dubious into genuinely sinister territory again. Watching him silently monitor Mercedes and the twins adds an unsettling layer to every scene moving forward.

Prince’s storyline also gains emotional depth thanks to Vicky. Her reassurance that he doesn’t need steroids to be attractive finally cuts through some of his insecurity, and their kiss lands surprisingly sweetly amid all the surrounding darkness. Of course, in soapland, moments of happiness usually come with a countdown timer attached.

BBC One, 7.30pm, stream on iPlayer

Walford is currently running on desperation, and EastEnders is absolutely thriving because of it. Mark’s situation becomes increasingly claustrophobic as every attempted solution creates a bigger problem.

The looming car scam has all the ingredients of a classic EastEnders disaster: financial pressure, family loyalty, criminal entanglements and people convincing themselves they’re still in control long after they clearly aren’t.

Grant offering financial help adds an interesting emotional wrinkle too. Mark refusing it feels rooted in pride and shame rather than stupidity, which makes his downfall more tragic than frustrating. Max quietly investigating him through Jack is also a smart touch — suspicion simmering in the background without immediate confrontation creates much stronger tension.

The kidnapping ending is classic soap escalation done right. One minute Mark’s debating whether to ask Grant for help; the next he’s being dragged into a van by masked men. It’s sudden, nasty and exactly the sort of cliffhanger EastEnders excels at when it leans into crime-thriller territory.

Meanwhile, Oscar and Josh’s storyline continues to unfold with surprising sensitivity. Their attempt to stay apart immediately collapsing under emotional tension feels very believable, and Penny becoming the accidental confidante adds another layer of complication.

Oscar’s jealousy at seeing Josh flirt elsewhere pushes him into finally acting on his feelings, and the kiss itself feels earned because the show has allowed the emotional confusion to simmer rather than rushing it.

Elsewhere, Denise quietly admitting she’s been feeling exhausted is the kind of understated soap foreshadowing that instantly sets alarm bells ringing.

ITV1/STV, 8pm, stream on ITVX/STV Player or YouTube

Emmerdale continues its current run of simmering paranoia and emotional power games, with Joe Tate sitting firmly at the centre of the storm. Dawn refusing to leave him despite everything is frustrating in exactly the way the show intends.

She’s trying to convince herself she still has agency in this relationship, but the arrival of Graham makes it painfully obvious Joe already knows more than he’s letting on. The sense that Dawn is trapped in a game she can’t win hangs over every scene.

Todd, meanwhile, is rapidly becoming one of the soap’s most unsettling presences. Her manipulation of Charity is almost playful on the surface, which somehow makes it worse.

Inviting Mack and Ross for darts while quietly prying into Charity’s personal relationships is textbook intimidation disguised as casual conversation. Charity realising she has absolutely no leverage left is a brutal moment, and Todd walking away triumphant leaves the power dynamic feeling genuinely dangerous.

There’s also something quietly heartbreaking about Sam trying to reconnect with Lydia after missing her dance class. In the middle of all the village chaos, it’s a reminder that small disappointments can hurt just as much as the dramatic betrayals.

And Aaron openly suspecting Joe of arson feels like the beginning of a much larger explosion waiting to happen. Nobody in the village trusts anyone right now — always a sign that Emmerdale is preparing to unleash absolute carnage.

ITV1/STV, 8.30pm stream on ITVX/STV Player or YouTube

Coronation Street keeps tightening the psychological screws around Summer, and the result is increasingly compelling. Lisa bringing her in for questioning after Kit’s discovery pushes the Theo storyline into genuinely tense territory, while George’s flashback hints that there’s far more to the night of Theo’s death than anyone realises.

Todd defending Summer adds an emotional layer too — there’s a sense that people are starting to choose sides before the full truth is even known.

The online abuse aimed at Daniel is another storyline that feels depressingly believable. The accusations connecting him to both Megan and his past with Summer tap directly into how quickly public opinion can turn toxic online.

Nina uncovering the posts creates a creeping sense of paranoia: somebody local clearly wants to destroy him socially, and the anonymity makes it feel even nastier.

Ben and Maggie’s family lunch is equally uncomfortable for entirely different reasons. Maggie desperately trying to hold the family together while Ben detonates the truth about Megan’s bail creates one of those classic Corrie scenes where polite domesticity implodes in seconds. The emotional fallout is messy, loud and deeply personal.

On a lighter note, Roy proudly unveiling the refurbished café is exactly the kind of grounding moment Coronation Street still does beautifully.

Amid murder investigations, online abuse and family breakdowns, sometimes Weatherfield just needs Roy showing off some new décor like it’s the event of the century.

Pick of the Plots logo