STV News shake-up approved by Ofcom – but viewers question impact on regional identity

Broadcaster says changes will secure the future of regional news in Scotland, while critics accuse Ofcom of weakening local television services

STV has welcomed Ofcom’s decision to approve major changes to its public service broadcasting licences, paving the way for the most significant overhaul of its flagship regional news service in two decades.

The broadcaster says the changes will allow it to continue delivering high-quality regional journalism while adapting to the realities of modern news consumption, where audiences increasingly access stories online and via social media rather than through traditional television bulletins.

Andrea Brymer, STV News (STV North Scotland Region) / STV

At the centre of the plans is a new structure for STV News at 6, Scotland’s most-watched television news programme. Rather than producing entirely separate programmes for its North and Central Scotland licences, STV will create two versions of the programme featuring a substantial shared section covering stories from across Scotland alongside dedicated regional segments tailored to viewers in each area.

Under the approved arrangements, up to 70 per cent of the programme can consist of shared content, while at least 30 per cent must remain specific to either the North or Central regions.

STV says its existing newsgathering operation will remain intact, with journalists continuing to work from Inverness, Aberdeen, Dundee, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Holyrood and Westminster. Presentation of the programme will move primarily to Glasgow, although the Aberdeen studio will continue to be used regularly.

Norman Macleod, STV News (STV North Scotland Region) / STV

The broadcaster argues the changes are necessary to reflect dramatic shifts in audience behaviour – despite the regional news on Channel 3 being highly watched – and will allow it to strengthen its growing digital news operation while maintaining a strong television presence.

Chief Executive Rufus Radcliffe said:

“We’re incredibly proud of STV News at 6, which remains Scotland’s most watched news programme, but like all Public Service Media companies, we must respond to the significant shift in audience behaviour.

“The changes Ofcom has approved to our licences will enable us to continue serving viewers with the high-quality, trusted national and regional news they expect from us. Crucially, this will be sustainable for our business and will be accessible on air and across all the digital platforms viewers now expect.”

He added that STV, as a commercial public service broadcaster that receives no public funding, must focus on ensuring trusted journalism remains viable for future generations.

Grampian Television Centre, 2005 / STV
Concerns Over Grampian’s Distinct Voice

Despite STV’s assurances, the announcement has prompted concern among some viewers and broadcasting observers, particularly in the north-east of Scotland.

Critics argue that the changes represent a dilution of the distinct regional identity that has characterised the former Grampian area for decades. Some have compared the move to producing a regional news programme for Birmingham from London, citing the geographical and cultural distance between Glasgow and Aberdeen.

One viewer wrote on social media: “Ofcom should be made to explain in great detail how this has been approved, as ITV provide full half hours across each region. And how disrespectful to the Grampian region.”

Others questioned whether the decision could create a precedent for wider reductions in regional television news across the ITV network.

ITV News Anglia, two shows, one live and on pre-recorded for the East and West of the region

Several ITV regions currently operate dual-region arrangements, with one programme presented live and another pre-recorded. Some fear broadcasters could now seek greater programme sharing elsewhere, potentially reducing the amount of truly local content available in areas such as Yorkshire, the Midlands and the West Country.

Questions For Ofcom

A significant portion of criticism has been directed at Ofcom itself rather than STV.

One viewer commented: “If Ofcom had any real powers they should have said to STV ‘you’re not in financial trouble, you’ve just spent millions on a radio station no one asked for. If you wish to make these changes the Channel 3 licence can be surrendered and we’ll open bids’.”

Another wrote: “I’m shocked at how useless Ofcom is. They allow big TV and radio stations cut back on things people want at the drop of a hat. But will spend months hounding community stations for minor infringements like only playing 49 minutes of local content rather than 50.”

A further social media post stated: “Ofcom is as much good as a chocolate fireguard. The broadcasters say jump, Ofcom jump, and go out of their way to please them. It’s why media in this country is in a complete mess.”

Andrea Brymer and Norman Macleod have been broadcasting news to the north of Scotland since the Grampian Television days of ‘North Tonight’ / STV

While such comments represent the views of individual viewers rather than established fact, they reflect a wider debate about the regulator’s role in balancing public service obligations with the commercial realities facing broadcasters.

The End Of A Historic Separation?

The controversy also touches upon a long-standing principle of Scottish commercial broadcasting.

When ITV services were originally established north of the border, Scotland was deliberately divided into separate franchise areas. The idea was to ensure viewers in different parts of the country received programmes reflecting their own communities, economies and priorities.

The Central Belt was served by Scottish Television, which launched in 1957, while Grampian Television began broadcasting in 1961 to serve Aberdeen, the Highlands and Islands, and the north-east. The arrangement recognised that Scotland’s largest cities, remote rural communities and island populations often faced very different issues deserving dedicated coverage.

The bold sound, animation and style of Grampian Television in the 1980s / Grampian

For supporters of the changes, the new structure reflects modern viewing habits and the need to preserve regional journalism in a challenging financial climate.

For opponents, however, the decision represents another step away from the localism that was once at the heart of commercial public service broadcasting.

The real test will come later this summer when the new-era STV News at 6 launches and viewers decide whether the promised balance between national storytelling and regional identity has been successfully maintained.

STV’s HQ in Glasgow

One Reply to “STV News shake-up approved by Ofcom – but viewers question impact on regional identity”

Comments are closed.