New research reveals most Britons prefer the Cornish way of eating a cream tea, as Costa launches a dual-swirl scone in a bid to unite jam and cream fans

The great British scone debate shows no sign of ending, but Costa Coffee believes it may have found a delicious compromise.
The coffee chain has unveiled a new “half-and-half” scone, featuring jam and cream piped onto the scone simultaneously using a specially designed dual piping bag, in a playful attempt to bridge the divide between Devon and Cornwall.
The launch comes as new nationwide research found that 71% of Britons believe jam should be spread first – the traditional Cornish method – while 29% prefer the Devonian approach of adding cream before jam.
The findings also reveal that the debate remains surprisingly passionate. Around 30% of people say they have “strong feelings” about the correct order of toppings, while 36% insist there is only one “correct” way to assemble a cream tea.
Costa chose Saltash, on the border between Devon and Cornwall, to launch its new creation, with the first dual-swirl scone served to the Mayors of Saltash and Kingsbridge in a symbolic celebration of both traditions.

Saltash Mayor Councillor Brian Stoyel welcomed the idea, saying:
“We’re proud that Saltash has become the home of Britain’s latest chapter in the great scone debate. The beauty of Costa’s 50/50 scone is that it celebrates both traditions rather than choosing between them. After trying it for myself, I can confirm it’s every bit as delicious as it sounds – proof that sometimes, bringing people together is even better than settling the argument.”
The survey also suggests afternoon tea is enjoying a resurgence with younger generations, with more than half (52%) of younger Britons saying the classic treat has found a new audience through TikTok.
Despite that renewed popularity, arguments over cream teas continue to run deep. More than a third (37%) admitted judging someone for preparing a scone the “wrong” way, while one in five said they have refused to eat a scone that wasn’t assembled correctly.
The debate even extends to pronunciation. While 55% of Britons say “scone” to rhyme with “gone”, 45% pronounce it to rhyme with “bone”. More than a third (36%) confessed to silently judging someone’s pronunciation, and 37% admitted correcting another person’s choice of words.

Even so, there are signs of peace breaking out. Around 57% of respondents said they would welcome a compromise allowing everyone to enjoy their cream tea however they prefer, while 79% agreed that the traditional cream tea remains one of Britain’s great culinary classics.
Costa’s Global Head of Food, Andrea Stewart, said the company wanted to celebrate both approaches rather than declare a winner.
“Our research shows Britain remains divided when it comes to how people top their scones, so we thought it was about time someone brought both sides together. Rather than choosing between two much-loved traditions, we wanted to create a playful compromise that celebrates both approaches and gives everyone a way to enjoy their cream tea.”
To coincide with the campaign, Costa Coffee has also brought its scones back to menus for the first time in more than five years.
Available in more than 1,000 stores, customers can also enjoy a new Afternoon Bundle, which includes a regular hot or iced drink with a scone served alongside jam and cream from £6.49 at selected stores until October 21, 2026.
