The ‘Vanishing Act’: How shame can be used to shift the blame

Psychotherapist Dr Judith M. Pilla examines a damaging tactic that can make the person who has been wronged appear to be the problem

Have you ever confronted someone about something they have done, only for the conversation to suddenly become about your reaction instead?

According to psychotherapist Dr Judith M. Pilla, this could be an example of what she calls “The Vanishing Act” — a shame technique in which the original wrongdoing effectively disappears, while attention is redirected towards the response of the person who has been hurt or offended.

Pilla explores the tactic in an illuminating article examining the role shame can play in relationships between partners, family members, friends, colleagues and employers.

The Vanishing Act, she explains, unfolds in three stages.

First, the instigator demeans or shames their target. The target then reacts to what has happened. Finally, the focus shifts entirely to that reaction, with the original behaviour effectively erased from the conversation.

A simple example might involve a couple. One partner repeatedly fails to keep an agreement concerning household responsibilities. When challenged, rather than addressing the failure, they accuse the other person of being “too emotional” or “always getting upset”.

The argument is no longer about the missed responsibility. Instead, the person who raised the issue is suddenly being asked to defend their behaviour.

Pilla describes this as a kind of sleight of hand: the attention is drawn towards the target’s reaction while the instigator’s original behaviour disappears from view.

The same dynamic can occur between friends. Someone makes a cutting remark about another person’s appearance, abilities or interests. When the target looks hurt or withdraws, the person responsible responds that they are “too sensitive” or claims they were “only joking”.

The original insult has vanished — replaced by criticism of the person’s response to it.

Pilla argues that repeatedly experiencing this dynamic can leave a target feeling confused and destabilised, particularly when they struggle to explain why the conversation keeps turning against them.

The consequences can become even more serious when the tactic is used to deflect responsibility for abusive behaviour. Pilla points to cases in which perpetrators deny or minimise their actions before focusing attention on the victim’s reaction, accusations or emotional state.

She also examines how similar patterns can operate on a much larger scale, suggesting that organisations, corporations and political institutions can use comparable tactics when confronted with criticism. Rather than addressing the behaviour that prompted anger or protest, attention can instead be directed towards those who are protesting.

For Pilla, recognising the pattern is an important first step.

Understanding the Vanishing Act can help someone identify when the subject of a conversation has been deliberately shifted — and distinguish between what happened and how they reacted to what happened.

“Shame is painful and personal,” Pilla argues, but its effects do not remain confined within an individual. It can spill into relationships, influencing how people communicate, respond to conflict and assign responsibility.

Her work explores shame not simply as an uncomfortable emotion, but as a powerful force capable of shaping relationships and behaviour.

Pilla’s forthcoming book, How Shame Runs the World: Harness the Revolutionary Power of Our Most Misunderstood Emotion, examines shame through historical, cultural and clinical examples. The book looks at how shame can manifest as anxiety, depression, anger, arrogance, silence, isolation, impostor syndrome, perfectionism and procrastination — as well as how it can affect relationships and wider society.

Judith M. Pilla, PhD, is a psychotherapist in private practice with more than two decades of experience working with individuals, couples, families and groups.

For the past decade, she has concentrated her research and clinical practice on understanding the problems associated with shame.

Her new book, How Shame Runs the World: Harness the Revolutionary Power of Our Most Misunderstood Emotion, is published on 1 September 2026.

More information is available at howshamerunstheworld.com