A study of almost 579,000 Steam reviews has revealed the horror games players describe as the most frightening

If you’re looking for a horror game guaranteed to keep you awake at night, The Mortuary Assistant might be the one to avoid.
A new study by video game news site Power Up Gaming has analysed almost 579,000 Steam reviews across 146 of the most-reviewed horror games, looking for fear-related words and phrases including “scary”, “terrifying” and “frightening”.
The results put The Mortuary Assistant at the top of the list, with 49.2% of the 5,439 reviews analysed containing fear-based terms.
Released in 2022, the indie horror game puts players in the role of a mortician working alone in a run-down funeral home. As they embalm the dead and carry out routine tasks, demonic entities begin to make themselves known, forcing players to identify and banish them.
Visage takes second place with 48.3% of its 5,322 reviews containing fear-related terms. The 2020 psychological horror game traps players inside a suburban house where terrible events have taken place, with changing rooms, ghostly families and no weapons to offer much protection.
Third is Layers of Fear, with 42.8% of 9,459 reviews describing the 2016 psychological horror title as scary, frightening or disturbing. Set largely inside the mind of a painter losing his grip on reality, the game uses shifting rooms, distorted paintings and increasingly unsettling surroundings to blur the line between reality and imagination.
Spooky’s Jump Scare Mansion ranks fourth at 41.8%, while Amnesia: The Dark Descent takes fifth place with 37.1%.
The Amnesia title, released in 2010, places players inside a dark castle with no weapons and little idea of what is happening. Exploration, puzzles, hidden creatures and a sanity mechanic combine to create an atmosphere of constant unease.
The 10 scariest video games
| Rank | Game | Fear-related reviews | Reviews analysed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | The Mortuary Assistant | 49.2% | 5,439 |
| 2 | Visage | 48.3% | 5,322 |
| 3 | Layers of Fear (2016) | 42.8% | 9,459 |
| 4 | Spooky’s Jump Scare Mansion | 41.8% | 8,427 |
| 5 | Amnesia: The Dark Descent | 37.1% | 9,044 |
| 6 | Five Nights at Freddy’s 4 | 37.0% | 8,692 |
| 7 | Demonologist | 35.9% | 8,868 |
| 8 | ROUTINE | 33.5% | 5,295 |
| 9 | Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs | 32.1% | 7,066 |
| 10 | Darkwood | 31.4% | 8,270 |
At number six is Five Nights at Freddy’s 4, the only entry from the hugely popular franchise to make the top ten. Released in 2015, the game puts players in the bedroom of a child who must listen carefully for approaching animatronics, checking doors, hiding under the bed and using a flashlight to survive.
Demonologist is seventh. The 2023 co-op horror game allows players to investigate haunted locations alone or with friends, collecting evidence and attempting to identify supernatural entities while avoiding becoming their next target.
Science-fiction horror ROUTINE takes eighth place. Set on an abandoned lunar base with a retro-futuristic 1980s aesthetic, the game sees players searching for answers while attempting to survive murderous machines.
The second Amnesia title in the list, A Machine for Pigs, ranks ninth with 32.1% of its 7,066 reviews containing fear-related terms. Released in 2013, it swaps the castle setting of The Dark Descent for Victorian London, where an industrialist investigates mysterious machinery and the disturbing events surrounding it.
Rounding out the top ten is Darkwood, with 31.4% of 8,270 reviews using fear-based language. The 2017 survival horror game places players in a dangerous forest, where gathering supplies during the day is followed by defending a hideout against whatever emerges after dark.
Chris Mawson, founder of Power Up Gaming, said the findings demonstrate that horror games can frighten players in very different ways.
“Part of what makes a horror game frightening is how effectively it keeps players anticipating what might happen next,” he said.
He highlighted Five Nights at Freddy’s 4 for its reliance on sound and reaction, while Demonologist and Darkwood use uncertainty and limited information to leave players feeling vulnerable.
Mawson added that the results also show horror does not need to rely on constant action, with atmosphere and exploration proving just as effective at creating tension.
The list includes games released across more than a decade, from Amnesia: The Dark Descent and A Machine for Pigs to newer titles such as Demonologist and The Mortuary Assistant.
