Professor Emmeline Taylor says pre-arranged buyers offer thieves a greater return, as a new Bira podcast examines the scale of retail theft and why many incidents go unreported

Shop thieves are increasingly stealing goods to order, with established networks of buyers helping to drive the crime, according to a leading criminologist.
Emmeline Taylor, Professor of Criminology at City St George’s, University of London, discusses the issue in the latest episode of High Street Matters, a podcast from the British Independent Retailers Association (Bira).
Titled Stolen To Order, the episode features Professor Taylor and Bira chief executive Andrew Goodacre examining who is behind shop theft, where stolen goods end up and why many retailers do not report incidents to the police.
Professor Taylor, who produced a report for the National Business Crime Centre on the destination of stolen goods, said thieves with a buyer already arranged can receive at least half the retail price of an item. This compares with around a third when goods are sold after the theft.
“There’s an economic incentive for the thieves to establish their network of buyers before they go and target items,” she said.
Goodacre said tackling the market for stolen goods could help reduce the incentive for organised criminals to target retailers.
“If you can close the market off for stolen goods, you do start to decrease the attractiveness of that market for the organised criminals,” he said.
Figures from the Office for National Statistics show police-recorded shop theft fell by 4% to 507,086 offences in the year to March 2026, following a record of around 530,000 the previous year. However, industry estimates suggest the actual number of incidents could be between 17 million and 20 million annually.
Professor Taylor cautioned against interpreting the fall in recorded offences as evidence that retailers were experiencing less crime.
“I would not yet suggest that that 4% reduction actually means an on-the-ground reduction in the level of criminality that retailers are experiencing,” she said.
Bira’s own survey of members in June found that more than 45% of retailers who had experienced theft did not report it to the police.
Goodacre said many independent retailers continued to feel they were being left to deal with the problem themselves. “There’s still this feeling that the retailers are out on their own trying to deal with a problem that has exploded in the last few years,” he said.
Professor Taylor also highlighted the impact of illicit businesses operating on high streets, warning that legitimate retailers could struggle to compete with businesses operating outside the law.
“Every time we allow one of those illegal businesses to thrive on the high street, it is directly putting another legitimate business out of business because they simply cannot operate on such an unlevel playing field,” she said.
High Street Matters is available through podcast providers by searching for ‘High Street Matters Bira’.
