The short lived series aired on ITV just over a decade ago…
Richard Osman has taken aim at one of ITV’s most infamous flops, branding Ant and Dec’s high-stakes game show Red or Black? an “absolute car crash”. The BBC quiz favourite, best known for Pointless and House of Games, reflected on the chaotic legacy of the short-lived series during an episode of his podcast The Rest Is Entertainment.
Fronted by Ant and Dec and championed by X Factor mogul Simon Cowell, Red or Black? promised huge nightly cash prizes — but failed to impress viewers, lasting just 14 episodes following its launch in 2011.
“After Deal or No Deal, it was like the Wild West for about five years,” Osman said. “The lesson TV bosses took was that people are happy to watch people be lucky. And that’s not the right lesson at all.”
Osman revealed that ITV exec Claudia Rosencrantz initially passed on the format, only for Cowell to pick it up — determined to make it the “biggest game show ever”.
“Simon Cowell takes this thing, suddenly it’s his idea. He says, ‘We’re doing this. It’s gonna be the biggest game show ever. A million-pound prize every night. Ant and Dec are gonna host it. It’s complete luck,’” Osman recalled.
“He said the Americans were gonna go crazy for it. It had great people involved, great people making it — but they must have known. It was an absolute car crash. It cost so much money.”
The show, which saw contestants simply gamble on red or black outcomes, struggled in the ratings despite its mega-budget production and star hosts.
“Four nights in a row they gave away £1 million,” Osman added. “Once they gave a million pounds to someone with a criminal record. It was an absolute mess. It was full of Simon Cowell’s Syco acts playing gigs in the middle of it, and Ant and Dec didn’t quite know what was going on.”
According to Osman, the show was quickly eclipsed in the ratings by BBC staples like Countryfile and Watchdog. “Nobody wanted to watch it,” he said. “They took the wrong lesson. We don’t want a game of chance — we want something that answers an interesting question.”
Red or Black? was quickly dropped by ITV who declined to comment to the media when approached about the comments. Ant and Dec however have had many long running successes with ITV, including I’m a Celebrity…, Saturday Night Takeaway and, more recently, Limitless Win.
