Criminals exploit ‘collapse of Trading Standards’

The exploitation is threatening independent retailers and high streets…

Independent retailers across the UK are facing a growing crisis as criminals increasingly undermine legitimate businesses amid a sharp decline in trading standards enforcement, warns the British Independent Retailers Association (Bira).

A recent investigation by consumer group Which? reveals that 36 local trading standards services reported zero criminal prosecutions in the 2023-24 financial year. Some teams have fewer than one staff member per 100,000 residents, leading to a significant drop in proactive inspections and enforcement actions against counterfeit goods, scams, and other illegal activity.

Bira, which represents over 6,000 independent retailers, says these findings expose a widening gap between law-abiding businesses and rogue operators who exploit weakened oversight to gain an unfair advantage.

“Criminal activity is growing whilst responsible, legal retailers suffer with a lack of support,” said Andrew Goodacre, Bira’s CEO. “We are losing control of the high streets and undermining legitimate independent retailers. We urgently need well-resourced trading standards teams to tackle the multitude of issues caused by criminals exploiting this lack of intervention.”

The Which? report highlights disturbing cases, such as cowboy builders intimidating vulnerable pensioners and dangerous counterfeit products being sold via online marketplaces. These illegal traders bypass regulations on business rates, health and safety, and product standards, enabling them to undercut legitimate shops that invest heavily in compliance and community trust.

Consumers also feel the impact, with many reporting frustration and helplessness when complaints about rogue traders go unaddressed. This growing sense of injustice contributes to a broader feeling that “Britain isn’t working for people who work hard and follow the rules.”

Bira stresses that the government’s new small business strategy falls short of addressing these enforcement gaps. The association is calling for urgent action to properly fund and empower trading standards teams to investigate and prosecute criminal traders effectively, safeguarding consumers and supporting the future of independent retail.

As high streets face mounting challenges, experts warn that without decisive intervention, the balance will continue to tip in favour of criminals — further damaging communities and the vital role played by responsible retailers in the UK economy.