BBC Eye has looked into the former Lebanese Shia leader who vanished nearly 50 years ago…
The Mystery of Musa al-Sadr, a documentary from the BBC World Service’s BBC Eye Investigations team, presents significant new evidence that may hold the clue to the fate of the Lebanese Shia leader who vanished in Libya in 1978.
On 25 August 1978, Musa al-Sadr, the Iranian-Lebanese leader of Lebanon’s Shia community, flew to Libya at the invitation of its then leader, Colonel Muammar Gaddafi. Three years earlier, Lebanon had erupted into civil war. Palestinian fighters became involved in the conflict, with many based in Lebanon’s south where most of Sadr’s followers lived. The Palestinians had begun exchanging fire with Israel across the border, and Sadr wanted Gaddafi, who supported the Palestinians, to intervene to keep Lebanon’s civilians safe.
On 31 August, after six days spent waiting for a meeting with Gaddafi, Sadr was seen being driven away from a Tripoli hotel in a Libyan government car. He was never seen again publicly. Al-Sadr’s disappearance sent shock waves through the Middle East, and politicians and journalists demanded answers from Gaddafi.
As BBC journalist Moe Shreif reports in The Mystery of Musa al-Sadr, no proven trace of Sadr has been discovered since that fateful day – despite dozens of subsequent journalistic and governmental investigations and many conspiracy theories. Some people believe he was killed, while others claim he is still alive and being held somewhere in Libya. BBC Eye presents significant new evidence that may hold the clue to the cleric’s fate.
Independent journalism was impossible in Gaddafi’s Libya, but this changed in 2011 with the Arab Spring. The documentary reveals how Kassem Hamadé, a Lebanese-Swedish reporter who was covering the uprising, managed to locate a secret morgue in Tripoli. He had been told he would find there the body of Musa al-Sadr, which was said to have been stored in the morgue for more than 30 years. Kassem photographed the corpse’s face.
As part of the BBC Eye investigation, the photograph was subjected to a facial-recognition algorithm developed by Professor Hassan Ugail at the University of Bradford.
In 2023, the BBC team travelled to Libya to find out what happened just after the last time Sadr was known to have been seen in public, and to visit the mosque in Tripoli where, they had been told, the cleric and Gaddafi had encountered each other.
The team managed to locate the building that had contained the morgue Kassem identified in 2011. They planned to film there the next day, but that night, they were told their filming permits had been revoked. The following morning, a group of unidentified men – who, the team later learnt, were officers from the Libyan intelligence service – seized the BBC team without explanation. For the next six days they were kept in solitary confinement and were repeatedly threatened and interrogated before being deported from Libya.
The Mystery of Musa al-Sadr goes on to examine claims that radical Islamist Iranian revolutionaries and Palestinian guerillas may have encouraged Gaddafi to kill Sadr. It also asks what happened to a sample containing DNA which Kassem Hamadé had taken from the body. He gave the sample for analysis to the office of Nabih Berri, the Speaker of the Lebanese parliament and leader of the Amal Movement founded by Musa al-Sadr. The Amal Movement has always maintained that Musa al-Sadr is alive and being held in a Libyan prison.
In 2024 the BBC team returned to Lebanon to show their findings to Musa al-Sadr’s son, Sadreddine. He said it was “evident” from the look of the body in the photo that it was not his father. He added that it also “contradicts the information we have after this date [2011, the year the photo was taken]”, that he is still alive, held in a Libyan jail.
The BBC has found no evidence to support this view. The corporation repeatedly approached the office of Nabih Berri for an interview and asked for comment on our findings. It did not reply. The BBC also asked the Libyan authorities to comment on the investigation and to explain why the BBC team was seized by the Libyan intelligence service. The BBC has received no response.
Almost 50 years on, Imam Musa al-Sadr’s fate remains a matter of extreme sensitivity.
The Mystery of Musa al-Sadr is available in the UK on BBC iPlayer.
International audiences can watch the documentary on the BBC World Service YouTube channel. The film also will be available in Arabic – via the BBC News Arabic TV channel, the BBC News YouTube channel, the website bbc.com/arabic, the BBC News Arabic channels on TikTok and Instagram; and in Persian – via the BBC News Persian TV channel.
