The diets everyone’s talking about…
From kale-heavy “skinny gene” claims to ultra-restrictive routines, Britain’s obsession with celebrity diets shows no signs of slowing. But doctors and dietitians are warning that some of the most talked-about plans are a fast-track to fatigue, rebound weight gain and long-term nutrient gaps.
Take Adele’s much-publicised Sirtfood diet, for instance. A mix of green juices, buckwheat, cocoa and even red wine, it went viral after the singer’s transformation. Yet the early phase slashes calories to around 1,000 a day. “It’s just another fad,” says Professor Clare Collins, a dietitian researcher. “The evidence is thin, and it’s unlikely to be sustainable.”
Then there’s Victoria Beckham, whose husband David revealed on the River Café podcast that she “only eats grilled fish and steamed vegetables.” She’s admitted herself that she rarely strays. Doctors say this kind of monotony risks missing key nutrients such as calcium, iodine, iron and fibre. As for the alkaline diet claims some of her fans swear by, experts stress you cannot change your blood pH with food — the science simply doesn’t stack up.
Simon Cowell, meanwhile, has widely credited a plant-based overhaul with his own weight loss. Doctors say vegan eating can be healthy, but there are common blind spots: vitamin B12, iodine and omega-3. “Fortified foods or supplements are essential,” says the British Dietetic Association. “Otherwise deficiency is inevitable.”
The pattern doctors consistently point to is Mediterranean-style eating: an abundance of fruit, vegetables, pulses, wholegrains, nuts and olive oil; fish a couple of times a week; and very few ultra-processed foods. The NHS, heart charities and Alzheimer’s researchers alike endorse it for weight management, heart health and even protecting against cognitive decline. It’s filling, fibre-rich and — crucially — easier to stick with.
For athletes, the rules are different again. Nutrition specialists at Minotaur Fight Store, which supports combat-sports competitors, emphasise performance-first eating. Fighters focus on carbohydrate periodisation — higher intake on training days, less on rest days — alongside 30–60 grams of carbs before hard sessions and steady protein across meals for recovery. Even weight cuts, they stress, are short, carefully planned strategies — not month-long starvation plans or juice-only “detoxes.”
So, what do experts advise?
-
Ditch: week-long juice cleanses, ultra-low-calorie phases, “alkaline” gimmicks.
-
Swap to: Mediterranean-style meals rich in plants, pulses, wholegrains, fish, olive oil and nuts.
-
If plant-based: plan in B12, iodine and omega-3.
-
If active: time carbs around workouts, aim for 20–40g of protein per meal, and avoid drastic cuts without expert guidance.
As one sports scientist put it: “What works for one body may not work for yours. The trick is to fuel, recover and adapt — not copy and crash.”
