Best on the Box choice for November 5th…
After nearly a decade of windswept investigations, Shetland returns for its tenth series — and it’s anything but a quiet life for DI Ruth Calder and DI Alison “Tosh” McIntosh. The BBC murder-mystery drama, now firmly established as a cornerstone of British crime television, plunges the detectives into a fresh case that stirs the secrets of a remote island community and tests the loyalties of the team to breaking point.
In the isolated hamlet of Lunniswick, the body of retired social worker Eadie Tulloch is found exposed to the elements — a grim discovery that reveals a woman seemingly forgotten by those around her.
“It’s such a typical Shetland setting,” says Alison O’Donnell, who returns as Tosh. “Scattered houses along a beach, neighbours who all know each other — and, of course, the history and secrets that lie beneath. There was so much to play with, so much to unpack.”
Eadie’s death draws Calder and Tosh into the heart of the village, where everyone has something to hide. Old friend Arthur Mair is consumed by caring for his ailing wife Lana, while their home now houses three generations under one roof — daughter Isobel, her struggling husband Tom, and heavily pregnant teenager Jess.
Then there’s David Powell, a young man with a troubled past, living under the suffocating protection of his mother Gina. As Tosh and Calder dig deeper, the picture of Eadie’s lonely final days becomes murkier — and soon, the case hits unexpectedly close to home for one of their own.
“It’s a story about community, about how the past haunts the present,” says Ashley Jensen, who has made Calder’s reserved strength and dry humour a defining feature of the show.
“Calder is more settled now — she’s unpacked her boxes, found her footing at the station, and even rebuilt her bond with her brother, Alan. She’s not the type to have a big social circle, but she’s happy in her own space. She’ll go home, have a glass of wine or two, heat up a microwave meal, and watch cold crime shows on TV. That’s her idea of contentment.”

Jensen laughs when she says it, but Calder’s solitary streak has always been one of Shetland’s quiet strengths — a reflection of the islands’ stark beauty and emotional restraint. “She’s tried a bit of online dating,” Jensen admits, “but honestly, she’s fine being single. She’s built this barricade around herself. Work fills her up.”
For Tosh, this new chapter marks a steadying of the soul after years of upheaval. “At the start of this new series, Tosh has really settled into her role as DI,” says O’Donnell. “Having reached a maturational threshold last season — realising certain relationships weren’t serving her — she’s focused now on what truly matters. Her relationship with Calder is blossoming, their dynamic is solid, and there’s real trust there.”
But this being Shetland, the personal and professional rarely stay separate for long. The victim’s link to Billy, one of Tosh’s oldest allies, threatens to pull the rug from beneath them both.
“It really tests Tosh,” O’Donnell explains. “She wants to support Billy — he’s been there for her all these years — but developments in the case make that incredibly hard. It’s about loyalty, friendship, and the toll that these cases take.”
The tenth series, says O’Donnell, is both intimate and expansive: a portrait of lives shaped by the land and each other. “It’s rich in history, relationships and secrets,” she says. “We dig deeper and deeper into the lives of those who live there — and the history of the place itself. It’s very satisfying.”
For long-time fans, the latest story is a reminder of Shetland’s unique balance: brooding mystery and emotional depth, held together by the bond between its detectives. And as the storm clouds gather once more over the islands, the question remains — how well do you ever really know your neighbours?
