Fake sparkle: experts warn of festive surge in jewellery scams

Synthetic stones flood the market…

If you’re planning to gift a little sparkle this Christmas, beware: that glittering gemstone might not be what it seems.

Luxury goods experts are warning shoppers to be extra vigilant this festive season, as synthetic gemstones and counterfeit jewellery become increasingly difficult to detect — even for professionals. According to Dawsons Auctions, one of the UK’s leading fine art and jewellery auctioneers, the growing sophistication of fakes and a collapse in the price of lab-grown diamonds has created the perfect storm for scammers.

Lab-grown diamonds, once touted as the ethical and affordable alternative to mined stones, have plummeted in price by 74% since 2020. Fraudsters are taking advantage — passing off cheap synthetics as high-value naturals and exploiting the boom in online jewellery sales. With jewellery accounting for over one in ten scams in the run-up to Christmas, Dawsons’ experts have shared their five top red flags to help buyers avoid falling for fake luxury.

1. “Too perfect” stones can be a warning sign

Flawless gems may actually be fakes. Genuine natural stones tend to have unique inclusions — tiny internal marks that act like fingerprints. Counterfeits, on the other hand, can look eerily identical or uniformly flawless.

Modern synthetics are so convincing that only specialist testing can tell them apart. Jonathan Pratt, Managing Director at Dawsons Auctions and a familiar face on BBC’s Bargain Hunt, warns that even experienced jewellers can be fooled. “Always ask for a grading report from an independent laboratory,” he says. “Reputable auction houses will have gemmological experts who can verify authenticity and prevent costly mix-ups — or worse, deliberate swaps.”

2. Beware of “ghost stores” and AI-generated listings

The rise of AI has given online fraud a new level of polish. Scammers are creating fake jewellery websites with realistic AI-generated product photos and tear-jerking backstories — retirement sales, bereavement clear-outs, and the like — to dupe shoppers.

Before buying online, check the business has a verifiable physical address, look up independent reviews, and search its name alongside words like “scam” or “complaint”.

3. Examine engraving and finishing closely

Authentic luxury brands use laser engraving with flawless consistency. Counterfeits often get the details wrong — uneven spacing, blurred letters, or mismatched fonts. Examine clasps, case backs and inner rings carefully under good lighting. If the engraving looks hand-done or sloppy, it’s almost certainly fake.

4. Weigh it up – literally

Real gold, platinum and high-grade steel have heft. If something feels unexpectedly light, that’s a red flag. Check for hallmarking such as “750” (18-carat gold) or “925” (sterling silver), and consult professionals if in doubt. Auction houses and established jewellers can verify metal composition on the spot.

5. If it sounds too good to be true… it probably is

Steep discounts and missing paperwork are the classic giveaway. “Authentic luxury items should come with original boxes, receipts and certificates of authenticity,” Pratt says. “Buy from qualified dealers who belong to recognised trade associations — that way, your purchase is legally protected.”

While counterfeit watches and handbags have long been a problem, the influx of affordable lab-grown stones has made jewellery the new frontier for scammers. “There are some extremely convincing fakes out there,” Pratt adds. “The safest route is to deal with reputable experts who have a name to protect — and who can prove what’s really behind the sparkle.”

Because when it comes to diamonds, it seems not all that glitters is gold — or even real.