Keala Settle and Hal Fowler to star in reimagined Mrs President

The production explores the haunted legacy of Mary Lincoln…

Broadway and West End heavyweight Keala Settle — best known for her breakout turn in The Greatest Showman and powerhouse performances in Waitress and Sister Act — is set to take on one of the most complex women in American history: Mary Todd Lincoln.

In a bold new reimagining of Mrs President, opening at London’s Charing Cross Theatre from 23 January to 8 March 2026, Settle steps into the First Lady’s troubled world — one of grief, ambition and public scrutiny in the shadow of her husband’s assassination. The play, described by its creators as a “reinvention” rather than a restaging, promises a deeper psychological dive into Mary Lincoln’s fractured legacy.

Settle stars opposite Hal Fowler, the veteran West End performer whose credits range from Les Misérables to Flowers for Mrs Harris. Fowler plays Mathew Brady, the pioneering photojournalist often called “the father of modern portraiture” — and, in this telling, the man Mary turns to in a desperate bid to reclaim her image from a hostile world.

“I was so struck by Mary’s story and the profound human cost she endured,” says Settle. “For centuries, she’s been put in a box — defined by other people’s ideologies. I hope audiences will see both myself and Mary in a brand-new light.”

Directed by Bronagh Lagan, whose Olivier-nominated Cruise and Flowers for Mrs Harris both drew acclaim for their emotional precision, the new production situates Mary Lincoln’s struggles in a distinctly modern context. Lagan calls it “a story about a woman under siege,” one that resonates in an age of political division and media distortion.

“In today’s polarised climate,” Lagan says, “Mary Lincoln’s navigation of grief, motherhood, and the public gaze feels deeply familiar. Her story forces us to consider how society treats women in power — and the emotional toll that visibility can take.”

Written by John Ransom Phillips, Mrs President first premiered in London in early 2025. This incarnation, backed by Art Pond Foundation and Aria Entertainment, arrives with a new creative team including designer Anna Kelsey, lighting designer Derek Anderson, and sound designer Eamonn O’Dwyer. Phillips himself describes the revival as “a reclamation” of history’s most misrepresented First Lady.

“History rarely grants women the right to define themselves,” he says. “Mary Lincoln least of all. This collaboration finally gives her the truth and artistry she was denied.”

The production’s scope extends beyond the stage. To coincide with the run, Phillips — also an accomplished visual artist — will unveil his first UK exhibition, Mary Lincoln and Frida Kahlo: UNFRAMED, at the Royal Watercolour Society Gallery from 30 January to 21 February 2026.

The show places Lincoln and Kahlo in dialogue, two women from different centuries united by pain, myth and creative defiance. Phillips’ watercolours and oil paintings, he says, “resist inherited narratives and invite new forms of seeing.”

Booking Link: https://charingcrosstheatre.co.uk/theatre/mrs-president-2026