And the high street brands where a size 14 really isn’t a size 14…
By Christmas Day, many of us will have consumed close to 4,000 calories in a single sitting – the equivalent, experts say, of more than a pound in weight gain. It is all part of the festive indulgence, until January arrives and more than a third of Britons vow to slim down.
For over half of those hoping to lose weight, the motivation is simple: not fitting into their clothes. But new research suggests that for many shoppers, the problem may not be the mince pies at all – it may be the label inside the dress.
An analysis by online healthcare provider ZAVA, examining measurements across major UK clothing brands, has revealed striking inconsistencies in women’s sizing. It found that the same “size 14” can differ by several inches depending on where you shop, with some brands offering far more generous cuts than others.
The most – and least – size-inclusive brands
At the top of the inclusivity scale sits Yours Clothing, which was found to offer the broadest measurement ranges across bust, waist and hips. Mango, M&Co and Fat Face also scored highly for providing wider and more consistent size options, giving shoppers greater chance of finding a comfortable fit without needing to size up.
At the other end of the spectrum is Primark, which recorded the tightest overall size ranges in the study. Miss Selfridge and Urban Outfitters also ranked among the least inclusive, offering comparatively narrow bust, waist and hip measurements across their ranges.
For shoppers, this means that two garments labelled the same size may fit entirely differently – a reality many women will recognise from a frustrating afternoon in the changing rooms.
The truth about a size 14
The findings are particularly stark when comparing size 14 measurements. At Mango, a size 14 offers one of the largest bust and hip dimensions on the high street. By contrast, Urban Outfitters, Monsoon and Primark produce some of the smallest interpretations of the same size.
In practical terms, a size 14 in one shop may feel closer to a 10 or 12 elsewhere – a discrepancy that can be as demoralising as it is confusing, particularly during the post-Christmas reckoning.
The psychological toll of inconsistent sizing
Dr Crystal Wyllie, a doctor at ZAVA, says inconsistent sizing does more than complicate shopping trips – it can directly affect mental health and weight-loss behaviour.
“Fashion sizes measurably affect our self-confidence and even our motivation to lose weight,” she explains. “If someone has lost weight but still can’t fit into a smaller size in a particular garment, that inconsistency can be deeply discouraging.”
ZAVA’s survey found that more than 50 per cent of adults who want to lose weight cite not fitting into their old clothes as their primary motivation. The emotional impact is particularly pronounced for women, with 73 per cent saying they have avoided wearing certain clothes because of their weight. For men, the figure is still a significant 52 per cent.
Other fashion-related triggers for weight loss include seeing oneself in photographs, upcoming holidays and weddings – all moments when clothes suddenly feel like public judgement, rather than personal choice.
“In an age of social media, changing body ideals and the unpredictability of online sizing, the impact of fashion on body image has intensified,” Dr Wyllie says. “It is crucial that clothing sizes are not seen as an objective measurement of health, beauty or worth.”
What this means for January shoppers
As the annual rush for “New Year, New You” gym memberships and wardrobe resets begins, the research serves as a timely reminder that the number on the label is far from a universal truth.
If your post-Christmas outfit feels snug, it may not be the leftovers to blame – it may simply be that your chosen brand runs small.
And in a retail landscape where a size 14 can span several inches across the high street, shoppers may be better served by the tape measure than the tag.
