Research suggests that the annual gifting exercise is becoming ’embarrassing’
Secret Santa may be sold as a bit of festive fun, but for many workers it has become a reliable source of awkwardness, quiet resentment and the occasional HR headache.
New research into workplace gifting suggests that around one in five employees have seen Secret Santa descend into tension, embarrassment or outright drama – from forgotten presents and blown budgets to gifts so misjudged they are still being talked about years later.
The survey of 2,000 UK office workers found that 19% had witnessed things going wrong, while only a third said they genuinely enjoy taking part – and then only when participation is optional. While four in five respondents described Secret Santa as “harmless fun” in theory, just as many admitted they would rather opt out altogether.
Cost is a significant factor. Almost one in five said they could not really afford to take part, even if they wanted to, highlighting the pressure that supposedly low-stakes workplace traditions can create at the end of the year.
Asked to share their most memorable Secret Santa experiences, respondents painted a picture of festive goodwill gone awry. Common complaints included regifted or used items, forgotten participants, and presents that missed the mark entirely. One worker recalled receiving used make-up; another described people being left out when colleagues failed to buy gifts at all.
More uncomfortable examples included joke or “adult” gifts that landed badly, alcohol bought for sober colleagues, chocolate given to someone with diabetes, and – in one case – lingerie gifted by a junior employee to their boss. Others recalled disciplinary action following inappropriate toys, or the minimalist offering of a rock wrapped in paper with “IOU” written on it.
Jay Singh, head of Moonpig for business, said the findings showed how quickly a well-intentioned tradition can unravel.
“Secret Santa is meant to be light-hearted and enjoyable for all, but it doesn’t always turn out that way,” he said. “Mismatched budgets and cringe-worthy presents can drain the festive spirit. Thoughtful gifting works best when it’s kind and inclusive, rather than trying too hard to be funny.”
With workplaces increasingly aware of inclusion, cost pressures and employee wellbeing, the research suggests that the future of Secret Santa may lie in making it strictly optional – or replacing it with simpler, less risky ways to mark the season.
