The festive offering saw a vintage character bumped off…
There was a time when EastEnders at Christmas felt like an event rather than an obligation.
This year’s offering, built around the surprise death of Anthony Trueman and the return of Chrissie Watts and the continuous circle of misery of Zoe Slater, certainly aimed for that old shock-and-awe energy.
What it delivered instead was something more dispiriting: a near beat-for-beat replay of past glories, wrapped in violence, coincidence and a sense that the show no longer quite trusts itself to do anything new.
On paper, the ingredients were irresistible. The Queen Vic. A corpse upstairs. Kat Moon, Chrissie Watts, Zoe Slater and Sam Mitchell circling one another like ghosts of Christmas past. It was nostalgia served by the shovel-load – but nostalgia with a nagging question attached: haven’t we been here before?
The answer, uncomfortably, is yes. So closely, in fact, that it bordered on self-parody.

A secret child. A showdown in the Vic. A body lying just feet away while characters trade barbed dialogue downstairs. For a show once celebrated for reinvention, this felt less like homage and more like rehashing, as if BBC Elstree had reached for its 2005 playbook and decided it would do just fine.
(Let’s face it forward thinking we all know went out the window with the 40th in February, a perfect chance for a ‘new exciting era’ heralded by a new look Queen Vic after its severe structural damage. What we got wasn’t even new wallpaper, it looked more like a quick touch up after an over excited hen party, taking the viewers for idiots in the process).
The new producing regime’s fondness for coincidence was everywhere. Characters conveniently arriving at the right moment, secrets tumbling out in precisely the right order, and confrontations stacking up with mechanical inevitability. That sort of heightened plotting can work – but EastEnders has traditionally demanded more emotional logic beneath the melodrama. Here, that logic often felt thin.
Anthony Trueman’s final day was undeniably packed. Having lied to Zoe about the fate of her twins, he was publicly expelled from the community Christmas dinner by Kat, before stumbling home to a devastating confrontation with his father Patrick, who suggested he wished Anthony had died instead of his brother Paul.
From there, it was on to the Vic, drink-soaked despair and an explosion of violence that left Zoe unconscious and Anthony fatally injured.

Whether that kind of brutality belongs on Christmas Day television is a debate as old as drama serial itself. This time, the audience response suggested exhaustion rather than shock. Ratings were notably soft, and social media reaction was savage, with some fans branding the episodes among the show’s worst festive efforts.
For Nicholas Bailey, though, the storyline carried a very different weight. Speaking about Anthony’s exit, he described being “honoured” to be given a Christmas Day departure, even as it marked the end of a stint that had brought him back into a show he clearly loves.
“A Christmas storyline is a huge moment in soap,” he said, acknowledging the bittersweet nature of leaving but praising the scale of what he was given to play.
Bailey admits he didn’t see the darkness coming. When producer Ben Wadey revealed where Anthony’s story was heading, “my jaw hit the floor,” he said. Looking back, he sees the logic: Anthony as a “pressure cooker”, bottling things up until the lid finally blew. It’s a thoughtful reading of the character – and one that perhaps deserved a more assured framework around it.
There’s genuine affection, too, in the way Bailey talks about his time on the show. Highlights range from Patrick and Yolande’s wedding to scenes with Jessie Wallace and Rudolph Walker, and the surprise of being reunited on screen with Michelle Ryan.

“I started this stint full of gratitude and I’m leaving with gratitude,” he says – a generosity that stands in stark contrast to the rancour surrounding the episodes themselves.
That contrast is telling. Because while Bailey’s performance anchored Anthony’s final days with real weight, the surrounding plot increasingly felt like spectacle for spectacle’s sake.
After Anthony’s death, the episode spiralled into a crowded final act: Kat discovering the body, Zoe facing off with Chrissie and Sam downstairs, Jasmine’s manipulation unravelled, threats issued, loyalties tested, and finally Zoe’s confession and arrest. It was loud, busy and relentlessly bleak.
The final images – Zoe calling Kat “mum” before being taken away as sirens flooded the Square – were clearly designed to echo the show’s past. Instead, they highlighted how reliant EastEnders has become on its own history to generate impact. Nostalgia can be powerful, but only when it’s in service of something new. Here, it felt like a safety net.
Anthony Trueman’s exit, by contrast, suggested what the show can still do when it trusts character over coincidence. Bailey embraced the scale and darkness of the story, even as viewers recoiled from the execution. That mismatch may be the most troubling sign of all.
Christmas EastEnders used to feel dangerous in the best way – bold, surprising, alive. This year, it felt dangerous in another sense: trapped in a loop, replaying its greatest hits while hoping audiences won’t notice how familiar the tune has become.

