Why Superstition still casts a spell…
There are few pop songs that announce themselves as confidently as Superstition. Before a lyric is sung, before a melody properly unfurls, Stevie Wonder’s clavinet riff has already done the work — coiling, prowling, daring you not to move. More than 50 years after its release, the track has now been voted Radio 2 listeners’ favourite Stevie Wonder song, beating off competition from some of the richest music in modern pop.
The result may not be surprising. Drawn from a shortlist of Wonder’s 60 most-played solo tracks on the station, Superstition topped the poll ahead of Sir Duke and For Once in My Life, claiming a kind of informal canon status among a listenership raised on soul, funk and melody-led pop. But its victory also says something about how Wonder’s music continues to function — not as heritage, but as something alive and physical.
Released in 1973 on Talking Book, Superstition was Wonder’s second US number one, a decade after he first topped the charts as a 13-year-old with Fingertips, Pt 2. It later won Grammy awards for best R&B song and male vocal performance, but its endurance has little to do with trophies. The song’s appeal lies in its tension — between groove and warning, pleasure and paranoia — a reminder that funk has always carried teeth.
That complexity is reflected across the rest of the top 10. Sir Duke, Wonder’s joyous tribute to musical heroes, lands in second place, its horn stabs and melodic generosity offering a sunnier counterpoint. For Once in My Life takes third — proof that his ability to transform a standard into something deeply personal remains as valued as his funk innovations.

Lower down the list sit songs that span decades and moods: the tenderness of Isn’t She Lovely, the open-hearted optimism of You Are the Sunshine of My Life, the social conscience of Living for the City, and the glossy inevitability of I Just Called to Say I Love You. Together, they form a reminder of just how vast Wonder’s catalogue is — and how difficult it is to reduce his career to any single sound.
The poll coincides with the 50th anniversary of Songs in the Key of Life, the 1976 double album often cited as Wonder’s crowning achievement. That record doesn’t produce the winner here, but it looms large over the countdown, a benchmark against which everything else is measured. If Superstition represents Wonder at his leanest and most propulsive, Songs in the Key of Life shows him stretching outward — socially, spiritually, emotionally.
Trevor Nelson, who counts down the 60 tracks on Radio 2 on New Year’s Day, calls Superstition “a stone-cold classic” with one of the best intros ever recorded. He’s right, though perhaps the song’s greatest trick is that it still doesn’t feel like a classic in the museum sense. It feels current — a reminder that great pop doesn’t age so much as accumulate meaning.
In the end, the vote isn’t about crowning a definitive Stevie Wonder song — such a thing probably doesn’t exist. Instead, it’s a snapshot of how listeners engage with his music now: still dancing to it, still arguing over it, still finding new reasons to return. If Superstition wins, it’s because it does what Wonder has always done best — it grabs hold, refuses to let go, and reminds you why this music mattered in the first place.
Top 10 Stevie Wonder songs, as voted by Radio 2 listeners
- Superstition
- Sir Duke
- For Once in My Life
- As
- Isn’t She Lovely
- You Are the Sunshine of My Life
- Master Blaster (Jammin’)
- Living for the City
- I Just Called to Say I Love You
- Lately
Trevor Nelson counts down the 60 songs in Your Ultimate Stevie Wonder Song on BBC Radio 2 and BBC Sounds
