Betting Markets React to Major BBC Twist…
The Traitors has barely begun, but betting markets are already in overdrive following the BBC’s dramatic introduction of a brand-new twist — the Secret Traitor.
According to CasinoBeats, retired detective Amanda has emerged as the early favourite to be revealed as Claudia Winkleman’s mysterious red-cloaked puppet-master, currently priced at 3/1. She leads a tightly packed field, with Judy close behind at 7/2, after viewers quickly began scrutinising early behaviour and edit clues in the opening episode.
An all-female top four dominates the market, with Fiona (4/1) and Roxy (9/2) also strongly fancied, while Ross (8/1) heads the betting among the male contestants.
CasinoBeats spokesperson Jeffrey McMillan said the unprecedented format change has turbo-charged speculation from the outset.
“Last night’s opening episode of The Traitors provided an unprecedented shake-up, with the identity of the red-cloaked Secret Traitor immediately becoming the biggest talking point,” he said. “The likeliest contestant is former police detective Amanda, who leads our market at 3/1 to be revealed as the unknown fourth Traitor. Following her in the betting is Judy at 7/2, with Fiona and Roxy also firmly in the frame.”

What is the Secret Traitor twist?
Claudia Winkleman wasn’t exaggerating when she warned viewers that The Traitors would be “a little bit different” this year.
Alongside selecting the usual Traitors from the 22 contestants — whose identities are known to the audience — Claudia has secretly appointed an additional Secret Traitor, whose identity is hidden from everyone: the Faithfuls, the Traitors, and even viewers at home.
“You are my Secret Traitor,” Claudia tells the mystery figure. “You will not be joining your fellow Traitors tonight. Instead, you will be controlling them.”
The Secret Traitor operates entirely alone and wields enormous power. They are responsible for drawing up the murder shortlist, from which the Traitors must make their kill. Crucially, only the Secret Traitor knows every player’s true identity, giving them a unique and potentially game-changing advantage.
Secret Traitor odds (via Poker Scout)
- Amanda – 3/1
- Judy – 7/2
- Fiona – 4/1
- Roxy – 9/2
- Ross – 8/1
- Ellie – 12/1
- Matthew – 12/1
- Sam – 12/1
- Bar – 14/1
