The High Street Matters podcast has discussed the topic in the latest episode
Artificial intelligence may still feel like the preserve of Silicon Valley and supermarket giants, but new research suggests independent retailers are sitting on a golden opportunity. The problem? Most haven’t taken it yet.
According to fresh consumer data discussed on High Street Matters, a podcast from the British Independent Retailers Association (Bira), shoppers are already using AI as part of their buying journey — but can’t point to a single retailer doing it especially well.
The gap between expectation and experience is striking. Research from global tech consultancy CI&T, which surveyed 2,000 consumers across the UK and Ireland, found that 61% have used AI tools while shopping, with more than half doing so regularly. Yet 68% couldn’t name one retailer offering a memorable AI-powered experience.
For independent shops, that mismatch could be an opening.
Shoppers are ready – retailers less so
“Consumers are embracing this technology, but there’s a huge gap,” says Melissa Minkow, global director of retail strategy and insights at CI&T. “Independent retailers who get this right now have a real chance to stand out.”
The research suggests shoppers don’t want flashy gimmicks. What they’re looking for is practical help:
- 63% want AI to save them time
- 61% want it to make finding products easier
- 58% want help securing better prices
In other words, AI doesn’t need to reinvent the high street — it just needs to make shopping smoother.
Why independents are well placed to act
While large chains may have deeper pockets, independent retailers have something arguably more valuable: close relationships with customers.
“What I love about independent retailers is they already know their existing customers really well,” says Andrew Goodacre, CEO of Bira. “AI gives them the opportunity to reach a whole new customer they don’t yet know.”
Unlike faceless online giants, independents can use AI to enhance — rather than replace — the personal service they’re known for: sharper product descriptions, faster responses to customer queries, more relevant social media content.
And crucially, the tools are no longer out of reach.
Start small, think human
The podcast highlights how free or low-cost platforms such as ChatGPT, Claude and Jasper can already help retailers write social posts, draft product copy and manage customer communications — without specialist technical knowledge.
The key, says Thomas Akintan, co-founder of SME-focused AI consultancy Avalon Insights, is not to overcomplicate things. “Start with simple use cases, test them, make sure your customers are happy, and make sure it works before rolling it out more widely.”
AI, he stresses, should support staff rather than threaten jobs — freeing people up to do what technology can’t: build relationships.
Trust is the dealbreaker
If there’s one area where independent retailers can genuinely outshine bigger players, it’s trust. The research found 83% of consumers say data breaches influence where they shop, with privacy their top concern about AI-powered experiences.
“Independent retailers can position themselves as the trustworthy alternative,” says Minkow, “by being transparent about how they use AI and what happens to customer data.”
In an era of faceless algorithms and endless data harvesting, honesty may be the most powerful differentiator of all.
Be curious — and be brave
Goodacre’s message to shop owners is simple: don’t wait for perfection. “If you haven’t explored ChatGPT, if you haven’t heard of Claude or Jasper, go and visit them,” he says. “Above all else, be brave. Retailers are naturally brave — they just need to explore what this technology can do.”
The High Street Matters episode, Smart Retail Revolution – How AI is Levelling the Playing Field for Independent Retailers, is available now. More guidance for independent retailers can be found via Bira.
For a sector under pressure, AI may not be a silver bullet — but right now, it looks like a rare chance to get ahead rather than catch up.
