The British Independent Retailers Association (Bira) has criticised the government’s decision to provide a business rates discount exclusively for pubs, warning that the move overlooks the mounting pressures facing high streets and independent shops across the UK.
Treasury Minister Dan Tomlinson announced at the start of this week that pubs and music venues in England will receive a 15% discount on their business rates from April and will be protected from increases for two years. While the package is worth around £1,650 for the average pub, Bira CEO Andrew Goodacre said independent retailers – facing identical economic pressures – were left behind.
“This is a poor decision based on politics rather than what is good for the local economy,” said Goodacre. “The Chancellor talks about thriving high streets, but support is being given to a sector where only 32% of pubs are actually located on high streets. Independent shops, which are closing at alarming rates, are excluded.”
Independent research from the University of Southampton appears to back Bira’s warnings. The study found that high street decline is the third most important local issue for voters, behind healthcare and crime, and suggested that governments that fail to address the crisis risk political backlash.
“We have the research, we have the data, and we have the warnings about electoral consequences,” Goodacre said. “Yet the government is supporting pubs while ignoring the businesses that actually define high streets.”
The scale of the problem is reflected in retail figures. The Guardian reports that the UK has lost 8,000 retail outlets since 2019, while Bira data shows 17,000 independent shops closed in 2024 alone, with similar figures expected in 2025.
Meanwhile, crime on the high street continues to rise. Newly released ONS statistics show more than half a million shoplifting offences in the year ending September 2025, a 5% increase on the previous year, alongside a 66% rise in robbery of business property.
“This is a retail crime crisis,” said Goodacre. “Our members report daily impacts, repeat offenders, and, in some cases, doubts about whether they can continue trading safely. We welcome the government’s commitments to increased neighbourhood policing and tackling organised crime, but we need speed of implementation and stronger penalties for repeat offenders.”
Bira argues that the government is missing an opportunity to support high street growth and investment.
The Treasury is cutting overall business rates support from £2.5bn in 2024 to £900m in 2026, while forecasts suggest rates income will increase by £10bn by 2030/31. “Business rates are being used as a cash cow instead of being reduced for everyone,” said Goodacre. “Supporting pubs while small retailers are being left to struggle is yet another half-baked U-turn that does nothing to address the high street crisis.”
With 87% of shop units reported as vacant in some areas, rampant retail crime, and the ongoing closure of independent shops, Bira says urgent action is needed to support the backbone of Britain’s high streets.
