From Slough to St Peter’s: Harry Clark and the awkward art of believing in public

Whether Clark ultimately meets the Pope matters less than the fact that he tries. His pilgrimage is not about proximity to power, but proximity to meaning.

There is something both quietly radical and faintly absurd about Harry Clark Goes to Rome. In an age of curated spirituality and TikTok theology, the BBC’s latest faith documentary asks an unfashionable question: what does it mean to try, sincerely and imperfectly, to be a “good” Catholic in modern Britain?

Airing on BBC Two and BBC iPlayer this Easter, the 60-minute film follows Clark – best known from The Traitors and Pilgrimage: The Road to the Alps – as he travels from his family home in Slough to Vatican City, armed with little more than nervous optimism and an unlikely ambition: to meet the newly appointed Pope, Pope Leo XIV.

It is, on paper, an audacious premise. Why would one of the most powerful religious figures on Earth make time for a reality TV alumnus from Berkshire? One of Clark’s friends voices the obvious: “Why would the Pope want to see you?” The documentary never fully answers the question – and that is part of its charm.

At home, Clark’s life is rooted in tradition. He still lives in the council house where he grew up, surrounded by family and faith. His Catholicism, inherited from his mother and grandparents, remains central. But it is increasingly at odds with the rhythms of his adult life: late nights, media events, dating, and the gentle drift away from weekly Mass.

This tension – between inherited belief and contemporary living – is where the film does its most interesting work. Clark is neither zealot nor cynic. He is, instead, something rarer on television: a hesitant believer, trying to reconcile devotion with doubt, ritual with reality.

Accompanied by his mother, Georgia, Clark travels through Rome’s sacred geography, testing his nerve at the Mouth of Truth, undertaking private confession, and attempting, often awkwardly, to re-enter a spiritual discipline he has half-left behind. The camera lingers on moments of embarrassment and vulnerability: missed prayers, nervous laughter, small admissions of guilt.

Alongside this inward journey runs the outward quest. Clark writes letters. He makes calls. He sends messages. He tries every conceivable route into the Vatican’s bureaucracy. The tone is lightly comic, but beneath it sits something more earnest: the hope that being seen, listened to, and perhaps blessed might validate his faltering faith.

As the narrative builds, he is granted a meeting with a cardinal close to the papal inner circle – a tantalising near-miss that becomes the emotional fulcrum of the film. It is here that Clark’s determination shades into something quietly moving. This is not celebrity entitlement. It is pilgrimage reframed as persistence.

For Daisy Scalchi, the BBC’s head of religion and ethics for television, Clark offers “a fresh, funny and very personal perspective”. She is right. His appeal lies in his ordinariness. He asks the questions many believers ask privately: Am I doing this right? Am I failing? Does it still count if I’m inconsistent?

Producer Karen Emsley of CTVC describes the film as a journey “into faith, family and identity”. That triad feels accurate. Religion here is not treated as spectacle or sociological curiosity, but as something embedded in kinship, memory and self-image.

Clark himself frames the project as a “once-in-a-lifetime journey”. Yet the film’s quiet achievement is to make it feel universal. You do not need to be Catholic – or religious at all – to recognise the struggle between who you were taught to be and who you have become.