“Fundamentally misdirected”: Retailers hit back at pub-only rates relief

The government’s latest attempt to shore up Britain’s struggling high streets has run into swift opposition from independent retailers, who argue that ministers have misunderstood both geography and economics.

In January, the Treasury confirmed a 15% business rates relief for pubs — a move framed as support for communities and town centres. But the British Independent Retailers Association (Bira) has described the policy as “fundamentally misdirected”, pointing out that only 32% of pubs are actually located on high streets.

In the latest episode of Bira’s podcast, High Street Matters, chief executive Andrew Goodacre questions the logic of targeting one segment of the local economy while excluding another facing many of the same — if not greater — pressures.

“It’s just wrong,” he says bluntly. “Only 32% of pubs are on high streets, bearing in mind the rhetoric from the Treasury has been about communities and high streets.”

The episode, titled Pubs Yes, Retailers No – Why the Government’s High Street Response Misses the Mark, also features John Jones, managing partner of Hereford department store Philip Morrison Sons. Between them, they paint a picture of selective support that risks deepening rather than alleviating town centre decline.

When business rates relief was first introduced in 2019, Goodacre notes, it covered retail, hospitality and leisure together — a recognition that these sectors coexist physically and economically. “Retail, hospitality and leisure occupy the same space on the same high streets and need the same support,” he argues. “For some reason, this policy seems to ignore that good practice.”

Jones expresses bafflement at what he sees as an uneven playing field. Retailers, he points out, face identical cost pressures — minimum wage increases, national insurance contributions, utilities and business rates — while also contending with what he describes as a retail crime epidemic. Theft from shops, he argues, is an escalating burden not mirrored in the pub trade to the same extent.

The criticism comes at a politically sensitive moment. Research from the University of Southampton has warned that Labour could face serious electoral consequences if high street decline is not addressed, with voters ranking the condition of their local centres among their top concerns.

For Bira, the debate is about more than fiscal fairness. Goodacre challenges the assumption that online retail can substitute for physical presence. “Two-thirds of all things are still bought in shops,” he says. “It’s a very poor society if we don’t have somewhere we can go, walk around, have some vibrancy.”

That argument — that high streets are social infrastructure as much as economic units — underpins much of the sector’s frustration. Independent retailers often position themselves as anchors of community life, providing not only goods but interaction, identity and continuity.

The government, for its part, has framed pub relief as a way to support communal spaces. But critics say that by isolating one type of venue, ministers risk undermining the broader ecosystem that keeps town centres alive. A pub without neighbouring shops, they suggest, is not the revival strategy being promised.

The row also highlights a longer-running tension over business rates reform. Retailers have consistently argued that the system penalises bricks-and-mortar operators while failing to rebalance the tax burden in the age of e-commerce.

Jones voices a note of weary realism. While encouraged that voters still value their high streets, he remains sceptical that policymakers fully grasp the urgency. “I’m not optimistic,” he says, “that the understanding from the decision makers is there in the short term to get this right.”

The latest episode of High Street Matters is available now.

For independent retailers, the message is clear: supporting high streets means supporting the whole street, not just the bar at the corner.