Debenhams tops wish list as shoppers call for high street comebacks

New search data reveals the former retail giants Brits most want back — as experts warn another tough year lies ahead for the sector.

With 2026 already seeing a string of household names enter administration — from Claire’s to Quiz — Britain’s high streets continue to face mounting pressure. As store closures rise and competition intensifies, new research has revealed which former retail favourites consumers most want to see return.

Analysis by Liquidation Centre, based on UK search data, ranks the top ten high street brands shoppers are longing to welcome back in 2026.

BHS sign in Glasgow, 2017 / ATV Network

Topping the list by a significant margin is Debenhams, attracting an average of 415,000 monthly searches. Once a 247-year fixture of British shopping, the brand was acquired by Boohoo in 2021 — though only its website and intellectual property were saved. While Boohoo has since rebranded itself as Debenhams, the company has confirmed it will operate as an online-only department store, with no return to physical high street locations planned.

Richard Hunt, Director at Liquidation Centre, said Debenhams’ struggles reflected years of mounting financial strain. “Failing to adapt to shifting consumer habits towards online shopping, combined with the financial impact of Brexit and the pandemic, contributed to its collapse. But the problems began much earlier, with unsustainable debt caused by poor financial decisions.”

Second place goes to Dorothy Perkins, with 40,000 monthly searches. Formerly part of the Arcadia Group empire, the brand was sold to Boohoo after Arcadia entered administration in 2020. Like Debenhams, it now operates exclusively online. Hunt notes that despite attempts to restructure through a Company Voluntary Agreement, high overheads and fierce online competition ultimately led to its downfall.

Shoppers go about their day in Newcastle, 2009 / ATV Network

Confectionery favourite Thorntons and heritage lifestyle brand Cath Kidston share third place, each drawing 24,000 monthly searches. Thorntons closed its stores permanently in 2021 after declining footfall and squeezed margins made physical shops unsustainable. Cath Kidston, following administrations in 2020 and 2023, was acquired by Next, which shifted the brand to an online-only model.

Nostalgia continues to shape the rankings. Woolworths, which collapsed in 2008 with £385 million in debt and more than 27,000 job losses, ranks fifth with 15,000 monthly searches. Its disappearance marked one of the most symbolic casualties of the financial crisis.

Children’s retailer Toys R Us places sixth, with 11,000 searches. The chain fell into administration in 2018, weighed down by debt, tax liabilities and changing consumer habits as children’s interests shifted increasingly towards technology and online retail.

Rounding out the top ten are BHS, Mothercare, Blockbuster, and JJB Sports — all brands whose closures left visible gaps on high streets across the country.

A vintage Woolworth & Co sign in Glasgow, 2016 / ATV Network

According to Hunt, the repeated pattern behind these collapses is clear. “The current economic climate poses increasing risks to retailers. It’s far easier to lose customers than retain them, which is why ongoing market research and competitor analysis are essential. Poor financial management has contributed to the downfall of several once-iconic brands.”

He advises businesses facing financial strain to conduct an immediate and honest review of income and expenditure, negotiate where possible with landlords and suppliers, and seek early guidance from licensed insolvency practitioners if necessary.

As 2026 unfolds, the message from consumers is unmistakable: nostalgia for the high street remains strong. But for retailers hoping to avoid joining the list of lost names, adaptation — not sentiment — will determine survival.