Environmental campaigner Ashley Smith and barrister Paul Powlesland discuss sewage pollution, water industry regulation and calls for a national survey of river pollution
The investigative podcast People vs Sewage has launched its dedicated YouTube channel as the programme expands its public rollout following an initial soft launch in December 2025.
Hosted by writer and commentator Philip Greenwood, the podcast’s first episode features environmental campaigner Ashley Smith and environmental barrister Paul Powlesland discussing the financial and regulatory systems behind sewage pollution affecting rivers across England.
Smith’s campaigning work helped inspire Channel 4’s Dirty Business, which dramatises the growing controversy surrounding sewage pollution in England’s waterways.
The episode explores the structure of England’s privatised water industry and arrives at a time of intense scrutiny surrounding Thames Water, whose financial position and debt burden have sparked debate about the future of the sector.
Debate Over the Future of the Water Industry
Policymakers are currently examining possible responses to the crisis at Thames Water, including the potential use of Special Administration under existing legislation or broader structural reforms to the water sector.
Proposals for reform range from emergency intervention measures to calls for full public ownership of water infrastructure.
The issue has also exposed divisions within parts of the environmental movement. While some campaigners support Special Administration as a temporary solution, others argue the situation highlights deeper structural problems that require more fundamental reform.
Campaign That Sparked National Attention
Smith is a former Detective Superintendent with Thames Valley Police who served in anti-corruption and serious crime units before turning his attention to river pollution.
His investigation into sewage discharges affecting the River Windrush helped bring national attention to the issue and contributed to the inspiration behind Dirty Business.
Speaking on the podcast, Smith argued that structural flaws within the current model of water management have contributed to ongoing environmental problems.
“The privatised water system was flawed from the outset. Over time it has developed into a structure where pollution can continue while accountability remains limited,” he said.
Powlesland said the scale of the problem remains poorly understood by the public.
“The majority of people do not realise how severe the sewage pollution problem has become. Rivers across England are affected, and the regulatory system has struggled to keep pace with the scale of the issue.”
Call for a National “Sewage Domesday” Survey
During the discussion, Powlesland proposed what he described as a national “sewage Domesday” survey to map pollution sources across the country.
Drawing inspiration from the historic Domesday Book, the proposal would involve a comprehensive effort to record every sewage outfall and discharge point affecting England’s rivers.
“What the country needs is effectively a sewage ‘Domesday Book’ – a national effort to map every outfall and discharge point so we can understand the true scale of pollution in our rivers,” Powlesland said.
The proposal reflects concerns that the true extent of sewage pollution remains poorly documented, with many discharge points not fully recorded within existing regulatory datasets.
The idea has since begun circulating more widely in environmental discussions. On 5 March 2026, Zack Polanski referenced the proposal during a discussion with environmental campaigner Fergal Sharkey on his podcast Bold.
A Platform for Long-Form Debate
Host Philip Greenwood said the aim of People vs Sewage is to provide a platform for deeper conversations about the structural drivers behind the environmental crisis.
“The sewage pollution crisis raises broader questions about how essential infrastructure is financed, regulated and governed,” he said. “The aim of the podcast is to bring together campaigners, legal experts and policy specialists to examine those questions in depth.”
Future episodes will explore topics including sewage discharge regulation, water company debt structures, infrastructure investment challenges and proposals for reform of environmental enforcement.
Watch and Listen
YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/@PeopleVSSewage
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/show/5Lk7N0d48AdTJwFQmoYufZ
Apple Podcasts:
https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/people-vs-sewage/id1858014703
