From Heated Rivalry to Wicked: the book-to-screen adaptations that impressed audiences

…and those that fell short

The past year has been a bumper one for book-to-screen adaptations, with filmmakers and streamers increasingly turning to bestselling novels for their next hit.

Anticipation is already building around Wuthering Heights, the upcoming take on Emily Brontë’s gothic classic from director Emerald Fennell, which many industry watchers predict could become one of 2026’s major box-office successes.

But not every literary adaptation has translated into on-screen acclaim. Some recent films — including The Housemaid, Die, My Love and People We Meet on Vacation — have struggled to match the enthusiasm readers had for the original novels.

New analysis compared reader ratings on Goodreads with audience scores on IMDb to determine which recent adaptations have come closest to matching — or surpassing — their source material.

Heated Rivalry named the best recent adaptation

According to the study, the most successful recent adaptation is Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid.

The 2019 novel — the second in Reid’s hockey-themed romance series — follows the secret relationship between rival hockey stars Shane Hollander and Ilya Rozanov. Already a fan favourite among romance readers, the book scored 4.31 out of 5 on Goodreads.

Its screen adaptation proved even more popular with audiences, achieving an 8.9 rating on IMDb — outperforming the novel’s review score by around 3.1%, making it the strongest performer in the study.

Other adaptations that closely matched the reception of their source material included Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, Hamnet by Maggie O’Farrell, and We Were Liars by E. Lockhart, all of which maintained strong audience ratings on screen.

When the screen version beats the book

Interestingly, only seven adaptations in the study managed to achieve higher audience ratings than their literary counterparts.

Among them was the acclaimed BBC drama Normal People, based on the novel by Sally Rooney. The series, starring Daisy Edgar-Jones and Paul Mescal, became a breakout hit during the COVID-19 lockdown in 2020.

Set between Sligo and Dublin, the drama traces the evolving relationship between Marianne and Connell, earning an 8.4 rating on IMDb — roughly 9.3% higher than the Goodreads score of the novel.

Another standout performer was Wicked, adapted from Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West by Gregory Maguire. The first instalment of the musical fantasy franchise proved a box-office success and earned award-season recognition, including an Oscar nomination for Ariana Grande and another for Cynthia Erivo.

Meanwhile, Netflix’s One Day, based on the novel by David Nicholls, also outperformed its source material. The 2024 series starring Leo Woodall and Ambika Mod follows two friends whose lives intersect on the same date each year, earning an 8.0 IMDb rating — higher than the novel’s Goodreads score.

When the book remains better

Not every adaptation impressed audiences to the same degree. Several titles in the analysis showed a sizeable gap between reader and viewer reactions, including The Housemaid, The Woman in Cabin 10, and Regretting You, where the screen versions received noticeably lower scores than their literary counterparts.

At the bottom of the list was The Man in My Basement by Walter Mosley, whose adaptation scored significantly lower than the original book’s Goodreads rating.

Despite the mixed results, the findings underline the enduring appeal of literary adaptations. With several high-profile novels heading for the screen over the next year, studios appear confident that the next big film or streaming hit may already be sitting on a bookshelf.


The research was compiled by gaming site McLuck