Pick of the Plots: Weekly Awards

As ITV has ditched, again, the British Soap Awards, we at ATV Today felt recognition should still be offered. So, for the spring and summer of 2026 let’s hand out the completely unofficial Pick of the Plots Weekly Awards — the moments that stood out for the right reasons, the wrong reasons, and the wonderfully ridiculous ones.


Best Moment

Remi finally admitting the truth about his brain tumour – Home and Away

Summer Bay often leans toward sun-drenched melodrama, but this storyline is hitting a surprisingly grounded note. Remi struggling with the shaking hands and then quietly telling Eden the truth about the tumour was genuinely affecting. It’s the sort of reveal that re-frames everything that’s been happening around him — his temper, the secrecy, the tension with Mackenzie and Cash.

The best part is that the show didn’t oversell it. No dramatic background music crescendo, just a horrible reality landing between friends. Soap illness stories can sometimes feel manipulative, but this one feels rooted in character, which is why it worked so well.


Worst Decision

Bear confessing to murder he didn’t commit – Emmerdale

Look, loyalty is admirable. Protecting your family is noble. But deliberately confessing to murder during a police interrogation might be one of the worst tactical moves seen in the Dales for quite some time — and that’s saying something in a village where people routinely bury evidence in nearby fields.

Bear’s decision to lie to protect Paddy was heartbreaking in intention but catastrophic in execution. Paddy’s devastation afterwards said it all: the kind of sacrifice that feels heroic in the moment but could ruin several lives long-term. Soap logic sometimes requires characters to make bad choices, but this one was painfully believable in its panic and desperation.


Most Bonkers Moment

A prison break plan… organised like it’s a group project – Hollyoaks

When Dillon revealed the plan to break Lucas out of prison and run away together, it felt like we’d briefly switched genres into a teen heist movie. Add Rex, James and Froggy forming a tactical alliance and suddenly the village looks like it’s running its own amateur escape committee.

The funniest part? Lucas is the only one acting remotely sensible, insisting he should serve his sentence. In a show famous for high-octane chaos, it’s almost refreshing when the supposed criminal is the calmest person in the room.


Dodgy plot building Moment

Bea opening a credit card in Honey’s name – identity fraud creeping quietly into Mother’s Day in EastEnders. Never a good sign.


Best Character

Eden – Home and Away

Stepping up, pushing Remi toward treatment, and still having the emotional bandwidth to forgive Cash (sort of). She’s the glue holding that whole storyline together right now.


Worst Character

Bear – Emmerdale

This is harsh because his heart’s in the right place… but confessing to a murder you didn’t commit again? At some point, someone needs to take the microphone away during police interviews.


Daftest Plot

The ever-expanding Warren/Jenson saga – Hollyoaks

Secret brothers, woodland kidnappings, sudden asthma peril… it’s like three plots stitched together and sent out into the world with vibes alone. Completely bonkers — and oddly compelling because of it.


Special Recognition

Pollard’s suspicious eyebrow – honestly doing more storytelling than some entire plots in Emmerdale.