“Insatiable” tops the list with a +45-point divide, as audiences and reviewers sharply disagree on a host of Netflix Originals
A new study has revealed the Netflix titles most unfairly dismissed by professional critics, despite strong audience support—highlighting a growing divide between critical opinion and viewer enjoyment.
The research, conducted by online bingo site Heart Bingo, analysed Metacritic data across a range of Netflix Originals. By comparing critic Metascores with average user ratings, the study identified the shows with the biggest positive gaps—where audiences rated them far more favourably than reviewers.
To ensure consistency, user scores were converted to a 100-point scale to match critic ratings, while titles with fewer than 50 user reviews were excluded to avoid niche bias.
Topping the list is Insatiable, which ranks as the most underrated Netflix Original. Despite receiving a low critic score of just 25, the dark comedy proved far more popular with viewers, earning a standardised audience score of 70—resulting in a striking +45-point gap.
In second place is First Kill, the vampire drama that recorded a +39-point difference. Critics awarded the series a Metascore of 45, while audiences rated it significantly higher at 84, underlining the disconnect between professional reviews and fan reception.
Third place goes to Gypsy (2017), the psychological thriller starring Naomi Watts. The series received a critic score of 45 but achieved a strong user rating of 82, marking a +37-point disparity.
Historical epic Marco Polo (2014) lands in fourth place, with audiences giving it a standardised score of 83 compared to a critic rating of just 48—a +35-point difference.
Fifth place is shared by workplace comedy Disjointed and fan-favourite Lucifer, both of which recorded a +32-point gap between critics and viewers.
The remainder of the top ten reflects a wide range of genres where audiences have consistently pushed back against critical consensus. Joint seventh place is held by Spartacus: Blood and Sand and Senna (2024), each with a +31-point difference.
Dynasty (2017) ranks ninth with a +30-point gap, while Messiah (2020) rounds out the list in tenth place, with a +28-point difference between critics and audiences.
The findings highlight a recurring trend in modern TV consumption: while critics may shape early narratives around a show, audience opinion often tells a very different story once viewers have their say.
