‘More evil and unpredictable’: The Creep Tapes returns bloodier

Mark Duplass reprises chilling killer Peachfuzz as cult horror series heads to Blu-ray

The warped world of Creep is set to get even darker, as The Creep Tapes Season Two arrives this summer — promising a more disturbing deep dive into one of indie horror’s most unsettling creations.

Created by Patrick Brice and Mark Duplass, the series builds on the cult success of Creep and Creep 2, continuing its signature found-footage style with six new episodes of psychological terror. Critics are already hailing the latest instalment as “stronger and more surprising,” with Bloody Disgusting calling it “a found footage triumph.”

At the centre is Duplass’ unnerving alter ego Peachfuzz — a chameleonic killer who records his increasingly bizarre encounters with unsuspecting victims. Each episode introduces a new “tape”, escalating the franchise’s mix of awkward humour and creeping dread.

Series two opens with a twist on the formula, as David Dastmalchian guest stars as a copycat killer who attempts to recreate moments from the original tapes — only to find himself entangled with the real thing.

Elsewhere, the series leans further into genre experimentation: from a sinister property show gone wrong, to a Saw-style escape room scenario, and even a darkly comic Christmas episode featuring an unconventional therapy session. The finale also sees Katie Aselton return, shedding new light on the killer’s disturbing backstory.

Blurring horror and character study, the show continues to explore identity, performance and manipulation — all through the unsettling lens of Peachfuzz’s camera.

The Creep Tapes Season Two is released on Blu-ray on 1 June 2026 via Acorn Media International, with all episodes already available to download digitally.