Fringe favourites return to Soho with a breakneck, gaffer-taped nightmare of ghosts, priests, and theatrical chaos—produced by the team behind Fleabag and Baby Reindeer
Hot on the heels of their upcoming Edinburgh Fringe 2026 run, Edinburgh Comedy Award Best Newcomer nominees the Crybabies—Michael Clarke, James Gault and Ed Jones—are transferring their new show The Scaring to Soho Theatre this September.
Reuniting with Olivier Award-winning Francesca Moody Productions and director Jon Brittain (Baby Reindeer, Kathy and Stella Solve a Murder!), the trio return to Soho Theatre following their previous critically acclaimed shows Bagbeard and Danger Brigade.
Described as a “terrifying tale of fear, faith, fathers (dads), fathers (priests), phantoms, and finally moving on,” the show follows former priest Arthur Holland, who checks into a remote hotel and quickly discovers the breakfast buffet isn’t the only thing threatening his survival. Teaming up with Gerry—the ghost of a long-dead guest—Arthur is forced to confront both literal and personal demons under the unsettling gaze of Mr Lyle, the hotel’s Norman Bates-esque manager.
The show blends absurd character comedy with classic horror tropes, escalating into increasingly surreal territory: Shakespearean zombies, broken-armed serial killers, and walking waxworks all feature in a narrative that constantly reinvents itself while somehow remaining (just about) coherent.

True to Crybabies’ reputation, the production moves at a dizzying pace, with rapid-fire costume changes and constant shapeshifting between roles. Despite the chaos, the storytelling remains sharply controlled—an increasingly rare blend of precision and pandemonium.
Visually, The Scaring pushes the group into more ambitious theatrical territory, while still embracing their trademark “ramshackle brilliance.” Expect low-budget ingenuity elevated into high-impact spectacle—effects built on suggestion, costumes assembled from scraps and set pieces that land somewhere between ridiculous and surprisingly effective.
The production also marks another major collaboration for Plosive Live, alongside Francesca Moody Productions—the team behind Fleabag, Baby Reindeer, and Kathy and Stella Solve a Murder!.
Speaking about the transfer, Crybabies said they’re “thrilled” to return to Soho Theatre, adding that given the world hasn’t become any less terrifying, they’ve decided to lean into horror—“and put even more boos into the Soho evening air.”
Francesca Moody described the show as “ambitious, surprising and truly terrifying,” praising the creative team’s mix of comic invention and theatrical boldness.
With The Scaring, Crybabies continue a steady ascent across stage, radio and screen, having developed BBC radio work and appeared in TV projects including Big Boys, Extraordinary, and After Life. Their cult following shows no sign of slowing—if anything, it’s getting stranger, louder, and more devoted.
