Unite attacks TfL’s £500,000 fatigue programme as bus drivers report worsening conditions

Union claims half-million-pound initiative failed to tackle root causes of driver exhaustion, with controversial sleep pods now reportedly being used for storage

Transport for London’s efforts to tackle bus driver fatigue have come under fire from Unite, which has branded a series of wellbeing initiatives “insulting” and ineffective after a recent survey suggested the problem has worsened for many drivers.

The criticism centres on a £500,000 fund established by TfL in 2019 following the publication of a report by Loughborough University into fatigue among London bus drivers. The money was allocated to a “fatigue, health and wellbeing bus safety innovation challenge” designed to improve driver welfare and reduce fatigue-related risks.

However, Unite argues that the schemes introduced under the programme have failed to address the underlying causes of exhaustion, including long hours, demanding shift patterns and insufficient recovery time between shifts.

A Freedom of Information request revealed that the funding was spent on 10 separate initiatives, eight of which focused specifically on fatigue. According to the union, all of the projects have since been rolled out across depots or buses but have done little to improve conditions for drivers.

Among the measures introduced were emotional wellbeing support programmes, health and fatigue management videos, and online educational courses designed to help drivers recognise and manage tiredness.

One of the more controversial initiatives involved the installation of two “Rest Space” sleep pods at Metroline’s Willesden depot. The pods, which reportedly retail at more than £10,000 each, were intended to provide drivers with a place to rest during breaks.

Unite claims the units, described by some drivers as resembling small cupboards, were largely rejected by staff and are now being used for storage.

Another project saw fatigue-detection technology introduced on buses. The Tenshi Senseye system monitored drivers’ eye movements and would trigger a seat vibration if signs of fatigue were detected. However, the technology was later removed from vehicles following the Covid-19 pandemic.

Unite General Secretary Sharon Graham said the measures failed to address the real causes of driver fatigue.

“These initiatives are insulting,” she said. “Bus drivers are being overworked to the point of extreme fatigue by the bus companies. Making them watch videos on wellbeing or take a nap in a cupboard in their depot won’t cure the problem.

“Fatigue is very serious and is caused by long hours, terrible shift patterns and the poor workplace conditions experienced by bus drivers. It is time this issue was treated with the importance it deserves and Unite will not stop campaigning until that happens.”

The union’s criticism is supported by findings from a recent survey of bus drivers, which found that around one-third believed fatigue had become “much worse” since 2019, despite the interventions introduced during that period.

Unite argues that current approaches place responsibility on individual drivers rather than addressing systemic issues within the industry. These include scheduling practices that leave drivers with limited rest between shifts, operational pressures that result in overtime being required to complete routes, concerns over welfare facilities and fears of disciplinary action if drivers report fatigue to management.

Regional officer Nadine Edwards said the findings highlighted the shortcomings of the programme.

“Simply put, TfL’s response was pathetic,” she said. “It is unsurprising that bus drivers have told us the problems with fatigue have become worse when the initiatives put in place essentially blamed workers rather than the bus companies who created the issue in the first place.

“TfL and Sadiq Khan must protect drivers and the general public. It is only by implementing Unite’s demands that the issue of fatigue will be properly dealt with.”

The debate over driver fatigue remains a significant issue for London’s bus network, with unions continuing to call for changes to working practices, scheduling and rest arrangements to improve safety for both drivers and passengers.