Phantom of the Opera inspired audiobook announces star-studded cast

Broadway and Hollywood performers join immersive new adaptation of Erin A. Craig’s Our Strange Duet featuring Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical world

Listening Library and LW Entertainment, the global entertainment company founded by Andrew Lloyd Webber, have announced the cast for the upcoming audiobook adaptation of Our Strange Duet by #1 New York Times bestselling author Erin A. Craig.

Set within the haunting and romantic world of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera, the immersive audio experience places Christine Daaé at the centre of the story, allowing her to tell her own version of events in her own voice.

Featuring a full cast, dramatic performances, cinematic sound design and official musical elements from The Phantom of the Opera, the audiobook will transport listeners into the gothic world of the Opera Populaire.

Produced by Audie Award-winning producers Julie Wilson and Kirby Crosbie, the recording brings together a cast of Broadway and screen talent led by Beatrice Penny-Touré as Christine Daaé, Jordan Donica as The Phantom/Erik and Jordan Fisher as Raoul, Vicomte de Chagny.

They are joined by Sierra Boggess as Carlotta Giudicelli, Tony Award winner Katrina Lenk as Madame Giry, Tony Award winner Norm Lewis as Ubaldo Piangi, Stephanie Styles as Meg Giry, Tony Award winner Jesse Tyler Ferguson as Monsieur Firmin and Dan Stevens as Monsieur André.

Penny-Touré returns to the role of Christine following her professional and West End debut in The Phantom of the Opera, where she first joined the ensemble before taking on the iconic lead role. She will also reprise Christine in the musical’s upcoming 40th anniversary season in London.

Speaking about recording the audiobook, she said:

“It’s been a magical experience recording this audiobook, and it’s something I’ve never done before. It is very special that it is a story that is so close to my heart, and very relevant in my life right now.”

Jordan Donica, who voices The Phantom, said the role has been a long-held ambition after first discovering the character through the stage musical.

“The Phantom is a role that I’ve always wanted to play. It’s the role that made me want to pursue the arts as a career.”

Donica, who made his Broadway debut as Raoul in The Phantom of the Opera, will take on the role of The Phantom in the upcoming 40th anniversary West End production.

Jordan Fisher, known for Broadway productions including Hamilton, Dear Evan Hansen, Moulin Rouge and Hadestown, voices Raoul and said the audiobook offers audiences a completely new way to experience the story.

“We’re getting to tell the story in a way that’s never been done before, never been heard before.”

Meanwhile, Sierra Boggess — one of the musical’s most celebrated Christines, who starred in the 25th anniversary production at London’s Royal Albert Hall and Love Never Dies — takes on the role of Carlotta Giudicelli.

Reflecting on the recording process, Boggess said:

“I’ve been associated with the show so many times as Christine but stepping in as Carlotta and getting to see her journey and go deeper than even what we see on the stage has been really enlightening and it’s also really fun.”

Our Strange Duet promises to offer fans a fresh perspective on the legendary Phantom story, combining Erin A. Craig’s storytelling with the atmosphere, music and drama of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s world-famous musical. Ages 12+, on sale September 1st, 2026.

Listening Library | Audio: 9798217348565