Warning over summer seafood trend

Experts warn that lemon juice can make raw fish look cooked – but it doesn’t make it safe…

A popular summer seafood dish could leave diners at risk of food poisoning, with an expert warning that lemon or lime juice does not actually cook raw fish.

Ceviche and similar citrus-marinated seafood dishes are particularly popular during warmer weather, with recipes regularly appearing across social media.

Traditional ceviche is made by soaking raw fish or shellfish in lemon or lime juice. The acidity changes the proteins in the seafood, making the flesh firmer, whiter and more opaque.

However, while it may look cooked, the seafood has not been cooked using heat.

Julian Klenda, a seafood expert at Maine Lobster Now with more than 14 years of experience in the industry, said the visual transformation is one reason the misconception is so common.

“Lemon juice can make seafood look cooked surprisingly quickly, which is why this misconception is so convincing,” he explained.

“The flesh may turn opaque and become firmer, but that visual change does not mean it has been cooked in the food-safety sense.”

Klenda warned that citrus should be viewed as a marinade rather than a substitute for cooking.

“Citrus alters the proteins, while heat also reduces harmful bacteria when food reaches the correct temperature,” he said. “Lemon juice should be treated as a marinade, not a replacement for cooking.”

Some recipes advise leaving fish in citrus juice until it becomes opaque, but this only indicates that the acid has altered its appearance and texture. It does not demonstrate that the seafood has reached a temperature capable of reducing food-poisoning risks.

UK Food Standards Agency guidance recommends thoroughly cooking food until the centre reaches 70°C for two minutes, or an equivalent time and temperature combination, to help kill harmful bacteria.

“If raw seafood went into the bowl, consumers should still regard it as raw when it comes out, regardless of how white or firm it has become,” Klenda said.

“Leaving it in the juice for longer will change the flavour and texture further, but it will not turn it into heat-cooked seafood.”

How to enjoy citrus seafood safely

For those who like the fresh flavours of ceviche but don’t want to serve raw seafood, Klenda recommends cooking the seafood first and adding the citrus afterwards.

Prawns, scallops, crab and lobster can be thoroughly cooked, cooled promptly and then combined with lemon or lime juice, onion and herbs.

Fish can be prepared in the same way, although its texture will be different from traditional ceviche.

“The simplest solution is to let heat do the cooking and use citrus for flavour,” said Klenda.

“Cook the seafood thoroughly, cool it promptly and keep it refrigerated. Add the lemon or lime juice shortly before serving for a cold, refreshing summer dish without expecting the marinade to do the work of heat.”

Those deliberately preparing traditional ceviche should also remember that it remains a raw or lightly treated dish.

Klenda advises against simply buying an ordinary piece of supermarket fish and assuming it will be suitable for eating raw after being soaked in citrus juice.

“Do not assume freshness alone makes seafood suitable for ceviche,” he said.

“It can look and smell fresh while still not being intended for raw consumption. Ask the seller, follow the storage instructions and never use seafood beyond its use-by date. Lemon juice cannot rescue fish that has been stored incorrectly or left out too long.”

UK government guidance states that fish intended to be eaten raw, or treated in a way that is insufficient to kill parasites, may require a specified freezing treatment unless it qualifies for an exemption. This can include certain marinated fish products.

Freezing can help control parasites, but it does not address every potential food-safety concern. Correct sourcing, refrigeration and hygienic preparation remain important.

Seafood should be kept refrigerated until shortly before serving, while raw products and their juices should be kept separate from cooked or ready-to-eat foods. Utensils and chopping boards should also be thoroughly washed after coming into contact with raw seafood.

“Citrus and seafood are an excellent combination, but lemon provides acidity and flavour,” Klenda concluded.

“If you would not be comfortable eating the seafood raw before adding the juice, the marinade should not change your mind. Cook it thoroughly first and add the citrus afterwards.”