Independent retailers say support should extend beyond the 20% discount proposed for pubs, clubs and live music venues

The call comes from the British Independent Retailers Association (Bira) in the latest episode of its High Street Matters podcast, which sets out a proposal that the organisation says could raise £6.5 billion for the Treasury by closing the low-value import loophole and tackling online VAT fraud.
Bira argues that the additional revenue could be used to fund wider business rates support for retail, leisure and hospitality businesses.
The episode, titled Message to the New PM, features Andrew Goodacre, CEO of Bira; Surinder Josan, former Bira president and owner of All Seasons DIY in Smethwick; and John Jones, current Bira president and managing partner of Philip Morris and Son in Hereford.
Goodacre says the current approach risks leaving much of the high street behind.
“Government support for reducing business rates has fallen from £2.5 billion in 2024 to £900 million today, and that’s being felt across the whole sector,” he says.
“We need a cohesive plan for high streets, not just picking off one or two sectors that could be a popular vote.”
Rising costs threaten independent shops
The podcast highlights the mounting pressures facing independent retailers, including rising operating costs, shoplifting and antisocial behaviour.
Josan says the increase in the cost of running a business is already affecting the make-up of local high streets.
“Our own cost of running a business has gone up drastically,” he says. “And the compounding effect of that inevitably is that we’re going to lose retailers.”
For Bira, the issue is not simply about individual businesses struggling to survive. The organisation warns that continued pressure could result in less diverse high streets, with independent retailers disappearing and being replaced by a narrower mix of businesses.
Jones argues that the business rates system itself needs fundamental reform.
He believes online and digital businesses should contribute a fairer share of the tax burden rather than leaving physical shops to carry a disproportionate amount of the cost.
“I firmly believe that the high street can look after itself if the tax regime allows it to,” he says.
£6.5 billion funding proposal
Bira’s proposal centres on closing what it describes as the low-value import loophole and tackling online VAT fraud.
Goodacre says these measures could generate approximately £6.5 billion for the Treasury, creating the opportunity to provide significantly greater support for businesses operating on the high street.
He argues that the money should be redirected towards the sectors that need it.
“The money should come back into high streets,” he says.
According to Bira, the £6.5 billion figure would be more than enough to fund a 75% discount on business rates for retail, leisure and hospitality businesses.
The organisation is now looking towards the autumn Budget and hopes the government will consider its proposals.
Bira says senior Treasury officials contacted the organisation the day after the announcement concerning pubs to discuss its concerns, which it regards as an encouraging sign.
What would success look like?
The podcast also asks what a successful high street would look like in 12 months’ time.
For Josan, the priorities are straightforward: less crime, lower energy bills, reduced business rates and a greater variety of shops.
Jones takes a similarly practical view, saying he would like to see turnover and employment at Philip Morris and Son moving in the right direction.
For Bira, the wider argument is that supporting independent retailers is about maintaining the diversity and vitality of Britain’s high streets — rather than providing isolated help to individual sectors.
The High Street Matters podcast is available by searching “High Street Matters Bira” on podcast platforms.
