Pacific islands rethink tourism to protect their identity as visitor numbers rise

From the Cook Islands to Fiji, destinations are exploring ways to grow tourism without losing the local culture, community ownership and natural landscapes that make them special

For decades, the traditional tropical holiday formula has been straightforward: build bigger resorts, add more rooms and attract more visitors. But across the Pacific, some destinations are taking a different approach, prioritising sustainable growth, local businesses and community-led experiences over the race to become the next mega-resort hotspot.

Dragonpass, the global travel and lifestyle benefits platform, says the shift reflects a growing challenge for island destinations: how to welcome visitors while protecting the character and communities that make them worth visiting in the first place.

From limits on building heights in the Cook Islands to Indigenous-led tourism initiatives in Fiji, the region offers a range of approaches to balancing economic opportunity with the pressures of increasing visitor numbers.

Tourism without turning into a tourist trap

Cook Islands: keeping the islands distinctive

The Cook Islands has made its low-rise development and relaxed atmosphere central to its appeal. Its tourism authority highlights the absence of branded resorts, buildings taller than a coconut tree and crowds, while its Destination Stewardship Plan focuses on protecting the qualities that make the islands distinctive.

Tourism contributes around 70% of the country’s GDP, making the industry vital to the economy. The challenge is therefore not simply to reduce visitor numbers, but to manage growth in a way that benefits local communities without undermining the destination’s character.

In July, the Cook Islands welcomed 21,728 visitors – equivalent to roughly 84 arrivals for every 100 residents in a single month.

With tourism already an important part of everyday life, the question is increasingly how the islands can continue to attract visitors without losing what makes them different.

Lelepa, Vanuatu: how much tourism can a small island absorb?

On Lelepa, where around 500 people live, a proposed private beach development could accommodate as many as 5,000 visitors a day.

The scale of the proposal highlights the dilemma facing smaller Pacific communities as tourism investment grows. A development capable of attracting thousands of people could bring economic opportunities, but it also raises questions about the pressure placed on local infrastructure, resources and the island’s way of life.

For destinations of this size, the challenge is deciding how much tourism can be accommodated before it begins to change the experience for residents and visitors alike.

Palau: prioritising value over volume

Palau is taking a more selective approach, focusing on high-spending visitors and lower-impact tourism rather than pursuing visitor numbers at any cost.

The strategy places greater emphasis on supporting local businesses and taking a cautious approach to future resort development.

By focusing on the economic value of tourism rather than simply the number of arrivals, Palau is seeking to ensure the industry benefits the country while limiting unnecessary pressure on its natural environment.

Fiji: putting Indigenous communities at the heart of tourism

In Fiji, the focus is increasingly on who owns and benefits from tourism, as well as how many visitors arrive.

The country’s new Indigenous Tourism Framework is designed to strengthen iTaukei leadership and ownership, helping ensure Indigenous communities receive a greater share of the industry’s economic returns.

The approach aims to create opportunities for locally led tourism businesses and experiences, giving visitors a closer connection to the communities and culture of the islands.

For travellers arriving through Nadi International Airport, Dragonpass also provides access to selected travel benefits, including the Fiji Airways Premier Lounge.

Samoa: tourism on local terms

Samoa offers another model, built around community involvement and locally run experiences rather than the enclosed mega-resort model.

Village-controlled beaches, local access fees and family-run beach fales – simple traditional-style beach accommodation – allow communities to retain a role in managing visitor experiences and generating income.

For travellers, this can mean a more direct connection with local life. For communities, it offers a way to welcome tourism while maintaining control over how their beaches and traditions are shared.

A different vision for island tourism

Across the Pacific, these examples demonstrate that tourism growth does not have to mean bigger resorts and ever-increasing visitor numbers.

The Cook Islands is emphasising careful stewardship, Lelepa illustrates the potential pressures of large-scale development, Palau is pursuing higher-value tourism, Fiji is strengthening Indigenous ownership, and Samoa continues to showcase community-led experiences.

Each destination faces different circumstances, but the underlying question is similar: how can tourism support local livelihoods without eroding the culture, environment and sense of place that attract visitors?