Destiny’s Child have landed the unwanted title of having the most irritating Christmas hit of all time, according to a new scientific study, while the Queen of Christmas, Mariah Carey, features twice in the top 10

It might be the most wonderful time of the year, but there’s one thing guaranteed to test even the most enthusiastic Christmas lover’s patience – the festive soundtrack.
And now science has weighed in on which Christmas songs are the most likely to have listeners reaching for the off switch, with Destiny’s Child topping a new study of 99 festive favourites.
The group’s 2001 hit ‘8 Days Of Christmas’ has been crowned the most annoying Christmas song ever, achieving an impressive 9.2 out of 10 in an analysis commissioned by an online ticketing platform.
The research examined both the audio and lyrics of 99 popular festive recordings, assessing them against four characteristics considered particularly irritating when heard repeatedly: musical repetition, shrill high-frequency sounds, harmonic dullness and the use of filler words such as ‘la la la’ and ‘ho ho ho’.
Each song was then awarded an Annoyingness Score out of 10, with the results arriving just as Christmas music begins its annual takeover of supermarkets, shopping centres, coffee shops, gyms and workplaces.
And while some songs might sound perfectly pleasant on the first play, the prospect of hearing them dozens of times before Christmas Day is apparently another matter entirely.
Destiny’s Child take the unwanted number one spot
Destiny’s Child’s ‘8 Days Of Christmas’ emerged as the clear winner – or perhaps loser – of the study, scoring highly across all four measures.
A remarkable 78% of its lyrics consist of repeated phrases, while 54% of its music repeats. The recording also has a particularly high proportion of shrill sound, with 21.2% of its audio energy falling within the high-frequency range. That’s almost three times the median figure across the songs analysed.
José Feliciano’s perennial festive favourite ‘Feliz Navidad’ takes second place with a score of 8.6. Every single word of the song appears in a phrase sung more than once, while filler sounds such as ‘la’ account for 12% of its lyrics.
Sharing third place are Kelly Clarkson’s ‘Underneath The Tree’ and Gwen Stefani and Blake Shelton’s ‘You Make It Feel Like Christmas’, both scoring 8.1.
The Jonas Brothers’ ‘Like It’s Christmas’ and Mariah Carey’s version of ‘Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)’ share fifth place with 8.0, while Darlene Love’s original recording of the latter song follows closely behind on 7.9.
Mariah Carey dominates the top 10
There is perhaps no bigger name associated with the modern Christmas music season than Mariah Carey, but the results suggest that repeated exposure to her festive catalogue might not be quite as welcome as she would hope.
Carey is the only artist to appear twice in the top 10, with ‘Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)’ sharing fifth place and her signature festive anthem ‘All I Want For Christmas Is You’ coming joint eighth with a score of 7.8.
The study found that 61% of the music in the latter recording closely repeats another section of the song.
Interestingly, of three versions of ‘All I Want For Christmas Is You’ included in the research, Carey’s is considered the most annoying. Vince Vance & The Valiants’ recording comes 19th, while Michael Bublé’s version is way down in joint 77th.
Among artists with multiple entries in the research, Carey also has the highest average Annoyingness Score, at 7.9.
SeatPick CEO and co-founder Gilad Zilberman said: “Mariah Carey owns December for a lot of listeners, so seeing her twice in the top 10 will surprise a few fans.”
Michael Bublé escapes festive irritation, but Taylor Swift doesn’t
While Carey might have some explaining to do, fellow Christmas music favourite Michael Bublé can breathe a sigh of relief.
The Canadian singer features more frequently than any other artist in the study, with 10 songs appearing in the analysis, including collaborations and duets. However, his tracks achieve an average score of just 4.8.
His highest-placed entry is ‘Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)’ in joint 21st place with 6.9, while his duet with Idina Menzel, ‘Baby, It’s Cold Outside’, is among the least annoying recordings in the study, ranking 94th with just 3.1.
Taylor Swift, meanwhile, fares rather less favourably. Her version of Wham!’s ‘Last Christmas’ ranks joint 14th with a score of 7.6, comfortably ahead of the original, which sits joint 27th on 6.6.
Band Aid’s ‘Do They Know It’s Christmas?’ finds itself somewhere in the middle of the pack, ranking joint 45th with 5.8.
The Christmas songs that really won’t leave your head
Beyond the overall rankings, the research also identified some particularly notable offenders in individual categories.
Pentatonix’s ‘White Winter Hymnal’ is the most repetitive song when both its music and lyrics are considered together. An extraordinary 79% of its music repeats, while 91% of its lyrics appear in repeated phrases.
However, the award for the most repetitive music alone goes to Trans-Siberian Orchestra’s ‘Christmas Canon’, with 89% of the recording closely repeating music heard elsewhere in the track.
For those who find particularly shrill sounds irritating, Run-D.M.C.’s ‘Christmas In Hollis’ is the one to avoid. It has the highest proportion of high-frequency sound in the entire study, with 40% of its audio energy falling into that category.
And if repetitive nonsense lyrics are your particular festive bugbear, Nat King Cole’s ‘Deck The Halls’ might be worth skipping. Some 71% of its lyrics consist of ‘la la la’ and similar sounds, accounting for 119 of its 167 words.
Pentatonix’s ‘Little Drummer Boy’ comes second in the filler-word category, with 68% of its lyrics consisting largely of repeated ‘pum’ sounds.
Even within the overall top 10, Bruce Springsteen’s ‘Santa Claus Is Comin’ To Town’ makes a notable contribution, with filler sounds accounting for 12% of its lyrics.
The least annoying Christmas songs
Thankfully, it’s not all bad news for those who enjoy a festive soundtrack.
At the opposite end of the rankings, Nat King Cole’s ‘The Christmas Song (Merry Christmas To You)’ has been identified as the least annoying of all 99 recordings, scoring just 2.5 out of 10.
Eartha Kitt’s ‘Santa Baby’ follows with 2.6, while Elvis Presley’s ‘Here Comes Santa Claus (Right Down Santa Claus Lane)’ completes the bottom three with 2.7.
So, if you’re already tiring of the annual festive playlist, perhaps it’s time to swap Mariah for Nat King Cole.
