A powerful new ITV documentary explores growing concerns from international experts who are questioning the evidence that led to the conviction of former neonatal nurse Lucy Letby.
A new and controversial ITV documentary is set to reignite debate around one of the most disturbing criminal cases in recent British history — the conviction of former neonatal nurse Lucy Letby.
Letby, who was handed 15 whole life sentences in 2023 for the murder of seven infants and the attempted murder of seven more, has become a symbol of unimaginable betrayal — a trusted NHS nurse turned serial killer. But Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt? asks a challenging question: was the conviction sound?
The programme brings together a number of international experts now working voluntarily with Letby’s new legal team. They claim that key aspects of the prosecution’s case do not withstand scrutiny and suggest that crucial medical and systemic failings at the Countess of Chester Hospital may have contributed to the babies’ deaths.
One of the central voices is Professor Neena Modi, a respected UK neonatologist and former President of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health. Speaking publicly for the first time about the case, she highlights severe concerns about care standards in the hospital’s neonatal unit between 2015 and 2016.
“This was a neonatal unit that was being required to care for babies it was not equipped to look after,” she tells the programme. “Some were clearly on a knife-edge… So these babies might not have died had their difficulties been addressed earlier.”
Professor Modi also raises concerns about the trial itself, describing it as appearing to have been “conducted with so many flaws”. The programme further challenges one of the prosecution’s central claims — that blood tests proved babies were deliberately poisoned with insulin. Helen Shannon, a chemical engineer, and Professor Geoff Chase, a leading insulin dosing expert, argue that what was presented as definitive proof of poisoning is in fact consistent with the normal biology of pre-term babies.
“We see no justification for the prosecution’s claim that poisoning was the only possible explanation,” Shannon says.

The documentary also includes the first on-camera interview with Karen Rees, former Head of Nursing at the Countess of Chester Hospital. Rees, who removed Letby from the unit in 2016, says she does not believe Letby harmed any babies. With further charges reportedly under consideration and a public inquiry led by Lady Justice Thirlwall underway, the case remains under intense scrutiny.
The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) defended the original conviction, stating:
“Lucy Letby was convicted of 15 separate counts following two jury trials. In May 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed Letby’s leave to appeal on all grounds – rejecting her argument that expert prosecution evidence was flawed.”
The CPS confirmed it is currently reviewing further allegations involving deaths and non-fatal collapses at both the Countess of Chester and Liverpool Women’s Hospitals. The Countess of Chester NHS Trust declined to comment due to the ongoing inquiry and police investigation.
Dr Stephen Brearey, a senior consultant who first raised concerns about Letby’s conduct, said:
“This case has been rigorously and fairly examined by two juries and reviewed by two separate appeal courts. My thoughts remain with the victims’ families as they continue to endure their tragic losses.”
Dr Dewi Evans, a key prosecution expert, rejected criticisms of his testimony, saying his evidence was delivered under oath, cross-examined, and validated by the courts. He dismissed the defence experts’ claims as “trial by speculation” and said their findings had not undergone the same scrutiny. Dr Ravi Jayaram, another consultant involved in the case, declined to comment.
