F1 safety fears explode after Suzuka crash as Verstappen exit talk grows

Up To Speed podcast hears fierce criticism of ‘Frankenstein’s monster’ cars and FIA response

Fresh concerns over Formula 1’s future have erupted following a dramatic crash at the Suzuka Circuit, with pundits warning the sport could be facing a defining crisis.

On the Up To Speed podcast, leading voices from across the paddock didn’t hold back, branding the current generation of cars a “Frankenstein’s monster” and questioning whether the sport’s latest regulations have gone too far.

Broadcaster Naomi Schiff warned that the incident was inevitable, saying: “An incident like this was bound to happen,” while Will Buxton went further, claiming: “They have to realise that what they’ve created is a Frankenstein’s monster that nobody wanted… this is dangerous.”

The criticism also extended to the sport’s governing body, FIA, with former driver David Coulthard suggesting warnings had long been ignored.

“The FIA has known that this was going to happen and did nothing,” he said, as calls grow for urgent changes to the regulations.

At the heart of the issue is a growing belief that drivers are no longer fully in control of their cars, with some arguing that the new technical rules have reduced the importance of skill and feel behind the wheel.

“They don’t feel in control of the cars that they’re driving. We’ve never seen that before,” Coulthard added, while Buxton claimed the changes risk erasing the gap between the sport’s elite and the rest of the grid.

The controversy has also fuelled speculation over the future of reigning champion Max Verstappen, with pundits suggesting his visible frustration could signal a potential early exit from the sport.

“There’s clear frustration there,” Buxton said, with Schiff adding: “If he’s not enjoying what he’s doing, the end of his Formula One career is near.”

Beyond safety and driver dissatisfaction, some fear Formula 1 is losing its identity altogether, as commercial pressures and regulation changes reshape the sport.

“Have they sacrificed a bit of the soul of what the sport is? I’d argue that they have,” Buxton said, describing the current era as “contrived and false”.

With key meetings now looming, the pressure is on the FIA and teams to find solutions quickly. As Buxton warned, the sport is “staring into the void” unless decisive action is taken.

The full discussion is available on Up To Speed, which can be streamed now via Global Player and all major podcast platforms.