BBC Sounds launches Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead

New true crime podcast revisits Diane Sindall case and wrongful conviction that shocked Merseyside

A powerful new podcast series, Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead, is set to launch on BBC Sounds, revisiting one of the most disturbing and unresolved cases in modern British criminal history.

Presented by Liverpool-based journalist Olivia Graham, the series explores the 1986 murder of Diane Sindall, a 21-year-old woman who was attacked and killed while walking home in Birkenhead after running out of petrol. Her death devastated the local community and left a lasting mark on the Wirral.

At the time, a conviction appeared to bring justice. But nearly four decades later, DNA evidence proved that Peter Sullivan—who had spent 38 years in prison—was innocent, leading to his release and exposing a profound miscarriage of justice.

The podcast examines how systemic failures and outdated investigative practices led to the wrongful conviction, while the real perpetrator remained unidentified for decades.

Returning to the area where Diane lived and worked, Graham speaks to residents who recall the fear that gripped Birkenhead in the 1980s, alongside long-standing doubts about the original investigation. Through interviews with criminal profilers, former detectives and forensic experts, the series reveals how the case went so badly wrong.

It also explores the wider context of women’s safety at the time, capturing the anxiety of a community living with the knowledge that an unidentified killer was at large.

During production, the investigation takes a new turn as Graham uncovers a potential lead, shedding fresh light on events in the weeks leading up to Diane’s murder.

Reflecting on the process, Graham said: “When we started this podcast, I never expected this would be the journey we’d go on. What I’m most proud of is how people have trusted us with their memories and stories… being from Merseyside has allowed us real access.”

The series also features audio from Sullivan himself, describing the moment he was exonerated and the personal toll of losing nearly four decades of his life to a wrongful conviction.

At its core, The Beast of Birkenhead is both an investigation into a miscarriage of justice and a renewed effort to seek answers for Diane Sindall’s family. The central question remains: who was truly responsible?

Chris Burns, Head of Local Audio Commissioning at the BBC, described the series as “an extraordinary, heartbreaking story” whose impact still resonates across British criminal history.

Produced by BBC Radio Merseyside and BBC Audio Scotland, the podcast is part of BBC Local’s slate of original storytelling rooted in communities across England.

Crime Next Door: The Beast of Birkenhead is available from Monday 20 April 2026 on BBC Sounds.