Trying again: Relatable flaws and second families

Esther Smith and Rafe Spall on love, adoption and five years of BBC comedy with heart…

When Trying first aired in 2020, it slipped into living rooms during a time of uncertainty and isolation. A comedy about a young couple unable to conceive, who turn instead to adoption, it struck a chord with audiences seeking both laughter and comfort.

Five years on, the show has grown into one of British television’s most beloved exports, with a global audience, a devoted fanbase, and a reputation for tackling delicate subjects with humour and warmth.

At its heart are Nikki and Jason, played by Esther Smith and Rafe Spall, whose chemistry has helped the series transcend its premise. Their journey through IVF, adoption panels and chaotic family dynamics is as much about resilience as it is about relationships. “It’s essentially a story about a family’s journey,” says Smith. “But the word trying also means trying in life. Every single character has something they’re dealing with.”

For Spall, the project was exactly what he had been waiting for: “I wanted to do a comedy that had heart. When the script landed in my inbox, I thought it was funny, relatable and about something that matters. That combination is rare.”

Smith admits she suspected early on the series might have “legs,” but neither star could have predicted the impact it would have — particularly within the adoption community, who have embraced the show as an honest, if heightened, reflection of their experiences. “I’ve had people who work in adoption say they’ve used Trying as a reference point,” Smith recalls. “It’s amazing when people come up and say the show helped them through something.”

Part of its success lies in Jason and Nikki’s imperfection. They are flawed, messy, neurotic — and therefore instantly recognisable. “They’re just everyday, normal people,” says Smith. “They try and fail, then get back up again, always with a laugh.” Spall agrees: “We relate to them because we see ourselves in them, but we also aspire to be them because they obviously really love each other. They row, but they come back together.”

The actors themselves have also evolved alongside their characters. Smith has become a parent since the series began; Spall, who jokes about having made “a lot of kids” in his own life, praises the show’s young cast. “We’re very lucky to have great ones in the show. It’s a joy.”

That balance — of heartbreak tempered with humour — is central to Trying’s appeal. Both stars credit creator Andy Wolton’s writing for its deftness. “In life, even in hard situations, something funny always happens,” says Smith. “Tragedy and comedy kind of go hand in hand.” Spall adds: “Comedy is very unifying. What’s better than unity in the face of pain? It’s representative of the human condition, which is to find the light in the dark.”

Their fondest memories are often of ensemble moments — family rows spilling across the dinner table, arguments that collapse into silliness. “Filming those big family scenes was a joy,” says Smith. “It’s lovely seeing all these dynamics play out together.”

That Trying has lasted five series — the latest currently filming for Apple TV+, while earlier runs return to BBC One — is testament to its universal themes. “The likelihood of anything being successful in showbiz is very low,” admits Spall. “What hits and what doesn’t is a strange sort of alchemy. But Trying is funny, it’s real, it’s heartfelt. And it’s global, which shows these things are universal.”

For Smith, the longevity is a gift. “It honestly feels like a second family now. It’s a joy to keep coming back into their world and seeing where the story takes them.”

And for audiences, Jason and Nikki remain the kind of on-screen couple we root for because they’re as flawed as we are. They try, they stumble, they laugh, they love. As Spall puts it: “It’s okay to fail, as long as you get up and try again.”

Trying returns to BBC One at 10:40pm on Mondays and is available on iPlayer.


Trying Series 5 is currently filming for Apple+