The Celebrity Traitors: Backstabbing for charity in the highlands

As Claudia Winkleman lures a fresh batch of famous faces into the misty Scottish castle, a pop star and a historian share what it’s like to play TV’s most devious game…

It’s back — but not quite as we know it. The Traitors, the gleefully gothic game of murder, paranoia and manipulation that turned everyday contestants into armchair Machiavellis, has gone celebrity.

Host Claudia Winkleman once again presides over the windswept Scottish castle, now filled not with teachers and insurance brokers, but with pop stars, actors, comedians and presenters — all pretending they can trust each other while quietly plotting each other’s downfall.

The rules are the same: a small group of Traitors secretly “murder” their fellow contestants, while the rest — the Faithful — must work out who’s lying to them. Except this time, there’s a twist of showbiz sheen: the winner (or the last Traitor standing) walks away with up to £100,000 for charity and, perhaps, a permanently raised public eyebrow.

For singer-songwriter Cat Burns, best known for her candid, emotionally rich tracks about vulnerability and self-discovery, The Celebrity Traitors offered a chance to show a side of herself that doesn’t usually get airtime. “It’s a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,” she says. “And I’ve always wondered if I’d be able to work out who the Traitors are — or if I could keep it up if I was one myself.”

Burns admits she’s “not really competitive”, the kind of person who just wants to “have fun” during Monopoly rather than start a family feud. But in The Traitors, niceness can be a liability. “My strategy would be to go under the radar,” she muses. “Don’t draw attention, but don’t say nothing either — that makes people suspicious. And I’ll try to read people, without looking weird. I stare a lot anyway!”

Still, Burns is more interested in self-discovery than subterfuge. “I’m quite physically fit, but I want to see if I can push myself mentally,” she says, grinning. “And I think people might see the lighter side of me. My songs are really emotional, but in real life I’m the least serious person ever. I laugh before I cry.”

If Burns brings youthful curiosity, David Olusoga, the broadcaster and historian behind acclaimed series like Black and British and A House Through Time, brings calm, cerebral detachment — or so he hopes.

“This show isn’t like anything else I’ve been asked to do,” he admits. “People I know who don’t watch anything else love The Traitors. There’s something so British about it — it’s a game, a murder mystery, and it’s in a castle.”

But despite his reputation for forensic thinking, Olusoga isn’t confident about his poker face. “I’d be a terrible Traitor,” he laughs. “I’ve got a bad memory. I’d forget I was undercover within a day. That’s why I’m not a spy.”

Instead, he’s relying on logic and persuasion. “I can build an argument,” he says. “Maybe I can use that at the Round Table. But reading people? No. My friends always tell me I’m terrible at that. I used to play poker — always lost. They could always tell when I had a good hand.”

It’s a candid admission that sums up The Traitors’ strange brilliance. Even those who understand strategy and psychology are undone by the sheer absurdity of the situation: the late-night paranoia, the alliances formed and broken, the creeping dread that the friend you just toasted might stab you (metaphorically) in the back before breakfast. “You can’t second-guess the producers,” Olusoga warns, with the knowing smile of someone who’s tried. “It’s like a forest of mirrors. You’ll just get lost.”

That mix of intellect and idiocy is part of the show’s enduring charm. Winkleman, with her velvet voice and fringe so impenetrable it might as well be one of the castle’s hidden rooms, presides over the chaos like a deadpan headmistress. And this year’s cast list — a who’s who of actors, presenters and comedians — promises even more double-crossing drama and awkward breakfast-table silences.

As for who might triumph? Burns has faith in staying true to herself. “I’ll leave it up to the universe,” she says. “If Claudia taps me on the shoulder, that’s what’s meant to be.” Olusoga, meanwhile, remains philosophical. “Winning? I haven’t even thought about it,” he says. “If I get murdered, I just hope it’s not by boring people.”

The Celebrity Traitors launches Wednesday 8 October at 9pm on BBC One and iPlayer, with two episodes per week on Wednesdays and Thursdays.